Posted in Maine Dining May 01, 2020 by

This Mouthwatering Ice Cream Trail In Maine Is The Sweetest Adventure In The State

I scream, you scream, we all scream for…eating as much ice cream as possible in one weekend in Maine! If you can’t get enough of this cold and creamy sweet treat, we recommend you jump in the car with your favorite people and check out the best ice cream in Maine.

From cones covered in sprinkles to cups overflowing with chocolate sauce, there’s not a bad option in the bunch. And, hey – if you’d rather have some solid alone time with your ice cream, leave everyone behind and make this a solo, self-discovery journey. No shame in that game. Or in eating an ice cream cone alone at the side of the road.

We’re aware that these uncertain times are limiting many aspects of life. While we continue to feature destinations that make our state wonderful, please take proper precautions or add them to your bucket list to see at a later date. If you know of a local business that could use some extra support during these times, please nominate them here: onlyinyourstate.com/nominate
To see the actual directions for this fun trip, click here!
Google Maps
1. Rococo Artisan Ice Cream Kennebunkport and Ogunquit
Rococo Artisan Ice Cream / Facebook
Rococo Artisan Ice Cream / Facebook
This is a good choice for those who are adventurous! We love travel and we love ice cream, so naturally an ice cream shop that's meant to represent flavors across the globe is our dream. The ice cream combinations are totally unconventional - things like Spicy Rocky Road and Nutella Cranberry grace the menu - and the classics are perfectly...classic! For more information, check them out online by clicking here.

6 Spring Street, Kennebunkport /207-251-6866
2. Kettle Cove Creamery and Café, Cape Elizabeth
Kettle Cove Creamery and Café / Facebook
Kettle Cove Creamery and Café / Facebook
There are so many flavors here, you'll have the staff answering questions for hours if you want to understand every single one. Instead, try something unique and thank us later. The coffee oreo gets rave reviews, as does the Maine blueberry. And, if they have it, get the ice cream that comes packed with Needhams! For more information, check them out online by clicking here.

2 Bowery Beach Road, Cape Elizabeth / 207-799-3533
3. Toots Ice Cream, North Yarmouth
Tim S. / Yelp
Toots Ice Cream / Facebook
Toots is another favorite! If you've got kids with you, they'll love meeting all the cows that live on this working farm. The ice cream is made right on the premises and the flavors are as unique as the feeling of eating your ice cream with barn animals. Try the Candy Store Floor, which is exactly what it sounds like minus any actual floor. For more information, check them out online by clicking here.

137 Walnut Hill Road, North Yarmouth / 207-829-3723
4. Dorman's Dairy Dream, Thomaston
R. E. / Yelp
R. E. / Yelp
If you don't know any better, you might pass right by this Thomaston establishment that blends right in. Unless it's a summer night with one of their signature lines. Get any of the flavors hanging in the window, but be prepared for a full cone - the portions are generous! And, they now take credit cards. For more information, check them out online by clicking here.

189 New County Road, Thomaston / 207-390-0121
5. Lulu's Ice Cream & Gelato. Rockland
Lulu's Ice Cream & Gelato / Facebook
Lulu's Ice Cream & Gelato / Facebook
A bit off the main strip in Rockland is Lulu's. This place is easy to miss, but we recommend you find it! They've got tons of creative flavors - things like Bourbon vanilla and gingery ginger - along with delicious sorbet and gelato. If you like enjoying your dessert outside, you'll love the shade trees and live music! For more information, check them out online by clicking here.

Oak Street, between Main and Union, Rockland / 207-226-1105
6. Stone Fox Farm Creamery, Monroe
Stone Fox Farm Creamery / Yelp
Stone Fox Farm Creamery / Yelp
Using Maine-sourced ingredients whenever possible, this homestead-loving ice creamery will have you tasting Vacationland with every lick. You'll find them in Monroe, as well as stocked in a variety of stores and at farmers' markets. You'll find Stone Fox Creamery's ice cream in various locations. For more information, check them out online by clicking here.
7. Gifford's Ice Cream, All Over Maine! (but let's go with Skowhegan for this trip)
Gifford's Ice Cream / Facebook
Gifford's Ice Cream / Facebook
This one needs no real explanation. If you're a Mainer, you know Gifford's. With locations all over the state, along with the original in Skowhegan, this place is pretty much synonymous with Maine. When you were in high school, there's a good chance you worked here as well! If you don't live near one of the five locations, you can always pick up a pint at your local grocery store. We love Muddy Boots and Maine Lobster Tracks! Don't worry, there's no lobster included. For more information, check them out online by clicking here.

25 Hathaway Street, Skowhegan / 207-950-2604
8. Butterfield's Ice Cream, Dover-Foxcroft
Catherin A. / Yelp
Butterfields Ice Cream / Facebook
The best thing about Butterfield's is that they ONLY serve homemade goodness! The ice cream flavors are unique - Mint Katahdin Breeze anyone? And the setting is lovely. Prefer your ice cream liquefied? They'll make anything into a milkshake! For more information, check them out online by clicking here.

136 W. Main Street, Dover-Foxcroft / 207-564-2513
9. Mount Desert Island Ice Cream, Bar Harbor
Mount Desert Island Ice Cream / Facebook
Eleanor L. / Yelp
While we hate to play favorites, we can't help it. This place just might be our favorite. With an incredible variety of creative flavors and super friendly staff, Mount Desert is just a nice place to end a day. Our favorite is Restaurant Buttermint (get it with chocolate chunks and it's the best mint chocolate chip you've ever had!) and the Blueberry Streusel. Another can't-miss? The Dude, which is a little like a white Russian for dessert! For more information, check them out online by clicking here.

325 Main Street and 7 Firefly Lane, Bar Harbor or 51 Exchange Street in Portland.
BONUS #10! Houlton Farms Dairy, Houlton
Houlton Farms Dairy / Facebook
Houlton Farms Dairy / Facebook
A stop here will take you slightly off-course, but we had to include it for the more hearty, ice-cream adventurers among you! If you find yourself in The County, THIS is the place to stop. Sure, they've got lots of fun flavors, but the real treat is the fact that everyone is friendly and kind. And, the word "dairy" doesn't just include the ice cream. Stock up on things like butter here too! Bring cash, because they don't take credit cards. For more information, check them out online by clicking here.

25 Commonwealth Avenue, Houlton / 207-532-3170

Who do you think dishes up the best ice cream in Maine? Let us know in the comments! While you’re out in Maine living your best life, consider checking out this fun hike. It has nothing to do with ice cream, but it ends in a beautiful waterfall that’s almost as nice as a homemade cup of the cold stuff.

Address: 6 Spring St, Kennebunkport, ME 04046, USA
Address: 2 Bowery Beach Rd, Cape Elizabeth, ME 04107, USA
Address: 137 Walnut Hill Rd, North Yarmouth, ME 04097, USA
Address: 189 New County Rd, Thomaston, ME 04861, USA
Address: 23 Oak St, Rockland, ME 04841, USA
Address: 398 E Main St, Searsport, ME 04974, USA
Address: 25 Hathaway St, Skowhegan, ME 04976, USA
Address: 946 W Main St, Dover-Foxcroft, ME 04426, USA
Address: 7 Firefly Ln, Bar Harbor, ME 04609, USA
Address: 25 Commonwealth Ave, Houlton, ME 04730, USA
The OIYS Visitor Center

best ice cream in Maine

May 15, 2020
Beth Price-Williams

What is the most famous ice cream shop in Maine?

If you’re looking for an ice cream shop in Maine that dishes up some of the biggest helpings of ice cream, look no further than the famous Fielder’s Choice. The family-owned ice cream shop offers some of the best homemade ice cream around. Choose from such delicious flavors as orange pineapple. You can also top your ice cream with an assortment of popular toppings – from peanuts to M&Ms.

For some of the best hard scoop ice cream in Maine, head to Beal’s Ice Cream. You’ll find multiple locations of the charming ice cream shop that sells all of the classics, like chocolate and vanilla, and some pretty unique flavors too. Try the whoopie pie or the peanut butter montage, for example.

Where can I find the best desserts in Maine?

Find some of the best desserts in Maine at Good Pie Bakery & Gourmet Kitchen in Belgrade. The charming bakery serves such delicious desserts as blueberry, meringue, and pumpkin. If you’re hungry for a meal, however, start by ordering a chicken pot pie, a spinach tart, or a homemade quiche.

If you love homemade pie, you can’t go wrong at Helen’s Restaurant in Machias. In fact, you’ll have eight taste-tantalizing flavors from which to choose – from wild blueberry pie to raspberry pie. Take your dessert to the next level with a hearty helping of vanilla ice cream on top. (Don’t forget to check out the meals menu too while you’re at Helen’s.)

Can I visit any drive-thru ice cream parlors in Maine?

Fielder’s Choice in Maine is the perfect spot to get ice cream from the drive-thru. However, if you prefer a walk-up window, you’ll definitely want to check out Red’s Dairy Freeze in South Portland. The seasonal ice cream shop has been a local favorite for decades, serving such favorites as freshly-made strawberry soft serve ice cream. Walk up to order your ice cream then chat with neighbors as you dig in.

Address: 6 Spring St, Kennebunkport, ME 04046, USA
Address: 2 Bowery Beach Rd, Cape Elizabeth, ME 04107, USA
Address: 137 Walnut Hill Rd, North Yarmouth, ME 04097, USA
Address: 189 New County Rd, Thomaston, ME 04861, USA
Address: 23 Oak St, Rockland, ME 04841, USA
Address: 398 E Main St, Searsport, ME 04974, USA
Address: 25 Hathaway St, Skowhegan, ME 04976, USA
Address: 946 W Main St, Dover-Foxcroft, ME 04426, USA
Address: 7 Firefly Ln, Bar Harbor, ME 04609, USA
Address: 25 Commonwealth Ave, Houlton, ME 04730, USA