Every state has unsolved mysteries, but in most cases they tend to be missing persons or murder. Kentucky  has its share of both, but some of ours have unusual circumstances. We also do have a few unique mysteries, and here are some of the most interesting unsolved mysteries in Kentucky:

1. On March 3rd, 1876, large chunks of meat "rained" from the sky across Olympia Springs in Bath County. A piece is still on display at the Arthur Baird Cabinet at Transylvania University. It is thought to be cyanobacteria, which is a gelatin-like substance.
Science Blog, University of Transylvania Display
2. In 1961, Betty Gail Brown, a Transylvania University student in Kentucky was found in a car on campus, strangled by her own bra. The case is still unsolved.
WN
3. In 1997, Erica Lee Fraysure’s car was found in a remote area of Brooksville, Kentucky. All her belongings and such were still there, but she has not been seen since.
W. Marsh
4. Mary Marrs Winebroad Cawein was found dead after attending a country club 4th of July party in 1965. It was determined she was drugged and then dosed with carbolic acid. The case was never solved, but 14 witnesses were called.
B. Bulicz

Related Stories

Escape To The Countryside When You Stay At This Rural Airbnb In Kentucky

Escape To The Countryside When You Stay At This Rural Airbnb In Kentucky

 This Is The Most Kentucky Sound You'll Ever Hear, And We Can't Stop Listening To It

This Is The Most Kentucky Sound You'll Ever Hear, And We Can't Stop Listening To It

 Take A Drive To The Country To Dine At This Exceptional Rural Restaurant In Kentucky

Take A Drive To The Country To Dine At This Exceptional Rural Restaurant In Kentucky
5. A John Doe was found in Daviess County in 1990, a few miles south of Philpot, Kentucky. The man had been stripped, bludgeoned, shot six times, along with having both hands and feet removed. The hands and feet were never found, nor was the killer.
W.marsh/Wikipedia
6. Valley Hill in Springfield, Kentucky, has been said to have showers of golden lights that cause some to have visions. This is still unsolved but has been investigated many times by paranormal investigators and even the TV show "Unsolved Mysteries."
Wiki
7. Octavia Hatcher of Pikeville supposedly lost her infant son to illness, and then took ill herself many decades ago. According to legend, she actually had a coma like disease which other neighbors then began to suffer. The lore is that when her husband had her dug up, there were claw marks on the coffin, but it has never been verified.
Viral Nova
8. UFOs in Hopkinsville have been a topic of discussion since 1955. A family saw little green men and commenced shooting. The case was investigated but never solved, however it was said horned owls might have been the invaders.
Chuck Miller

The Bluegrass State has a few pages worth of murder and missing person cases still unsolved. Some of these other mysteries were very unique to Kentucky though. It isn’t every day we hear about aliens or clawed up coffins from the inside. If you or anyone you know has an interesting mystery to share from the Commonwealth, or know of any other unsolved mysteries in Kentucky, feel free to share them in the comments below.

OnlyInYourState may earn compensation through affiliate links in this article. As an Amazon Associate, we earn from qualifying purchases.

More to Explore

unsolved mysteries in Kentucky

Sarah M. | December 24, 2022

What are some other mysteries and legends in Kentucky?

The Bluegrass State is big on history, with plenty of local lore and legends mixed in for good measure, too. One of the most infamous and chilling legends in Kentucky that’s been passed down in hushed whispers around campfires is that of the Pope Lick Monster. The Pope Lick Monster — or “Goat Man,” as he’s colloquially referred — is a beast that’s part man, part goat, and part sheep. He’s reported to live beneath a railroad trestle bridge over Kentucky’s Pope Lick Creek, a location that’s seen more than its fair share of tragedy and sorrow throughout the years. Just outside of Louisville, in eastern Jefferson County, the Norfolk Southern Railroad runs right through the Parklands of Floyds Fork -- and it's within this particular stretch of trestle that the Pope Lick Monster is said to reside. Part man, part goat, and part sheep, rumors of a hideous beast roaming around the Pope Lick Trestle have been swirling for quite some time! You can learn more about this tragic legend in Kentucky in this article, and please, take note: while it’s fascinating to talk about, we absolutely do not recommend putting yourself in danger to see for yourself if this legend is true.

Related Articles