Guess what, pie fans? It's no secret that you can find some genuinely delectable, one-of-a-kind pie shops in Indiana, but sometimes you really crave that homemade taste and feel that often pies sold in shops don't offer. Enter Sue & Kim's Pies, a haven for (literally) homemade pies the whole family is sure to fall in love with. While it technically has no physical business location, it sells its amazing pies at farmers' markets as well as offers delivery! For the best homemade pies in Indiana - literally - get ahold of the fine lady at Sue & Kim's. You will not regret it.
Don't let the simple appearance of the website fool you; the pies made at this little place are seriously among the best you'll ever have.
You can come to pick your order up, have it delivered, or simply try your luck at finding them at the next farmers' market. Note: This pie business is run out of the owner's home; please do NOT simply show up. Place an order online or by calling before, please!
The pie options are amazing, and Sue & Kim's offers some of the best of the best.
Often hailed as having the best pies in northwestern Indiana, it's no surprise why Sue & Kim's is a tried-and-true favorite among the locals.
What's your favorite flavor?
No matter what it is, you're sure to find the downright greatest version of it here. It all started in 2019 when owner Kim decided to turn her lifelong passion for crafting delicious, flaky, buttery pies into a career.
Using her mother Sue's recipes, she created a tour de force of flavor that Hoosiers cannot get enough of.
There's something magical about legitimate homemade goodies that takes us back to a simpler time. Maybe it's because they remind us of home. Maybe it's because they're delicious. Maybe it's both, and then some.
Resist the urge to buy one of everything.
...or don't, it's fine. We're not here to judge.
Sue & Kim's is open seven days a week for pick up and delivery.
Be sure to visit the official website for the most up-to-date menu, specials, and offerings.
So, truly, for the best homemade pies in Indiana, it doesn't get better than Sue & Kim's. Be sure to order well in advance - these pies sell fast.
Can't get enough of Indiana's amazing food and drink options? We have plenty more for you - be sure to check out these bucket list affordable restaurants in Indiana. Your wallet will thank you!
Subscribe to our newsletter
Get the latest updates and news
Thank you for subscribing!