This Unique Bagel Shop Is the Best Place to Get an Authentic Pizza Bagel in Milwaukee, Wisconsin

Do you know what they say about things like Reese’s Peanut Butter Cups and peanut butter and jelly or peanut butter and banana? No, it's not, "Why does everything taste good with peanut butter?" (Seriously, I'm looking at you, Buckeyes!) I’m talking about, “Two great tastes that taste great together.” And you know what else falls into this category? The pizza bagel.

But wait, I’m not talking about those tiny bagel bites with sad square pepperonis that remind you of high school cafeteria pizza. Oh no. I’m talking about the pizza bagel elevated to new heights. Picture the chewiest, fluffiest bagel you’ve ever eaten, brushed with garlic butter, topped with the richest tomato sauce, and loaded with the perfect blend of cheeses. That’s what you’ll get at Allie Boy’s Bagelry & Luncheonette in Milwaukee.

Allie Boy's was created by Staci and Ben, who combine their diverse backgrounds into an unforgettable culinary experience. Staci grew up in New York, while Ben spent part of his childhood overseas in the Middle East. This fusion of cultures shines in the menu. Today, in their new Milwaukee home, Allie Boy's offers flavors from Ben's home, with Midwestern hospitality to match.

If you're a flavor lover, Allie Boy’s is a must-visit stop. Tucked into a vibrant Milwaukee neighborhood full of local shops, craft breweries, and outdoor spaces, it’s the perfect place to discover your new favorite bagel and schmear combination. Nearby, you can catch a Brewers game or enjoy a stroll around the Milwaukee Public Market. The decor is cozy and stylish, with a funky yet inviting vibe. The staff? Friendly and full of personality.

Now, let’s talk about the star of the show: the Pizza Bagel Tartine. It starts with a garlic butter-brushed bagel, topped with zesty house-made tomato sauce, mozzarella, provolone, and pecorino, finished with fresh basil. This pizza bagel is everything you want - crispy, cheesy, and saucy.

And if you’re feeling adventurous, you can opt for the rotating special, which currently features Nduja sausage, broccolini, fresh mozzarella, Calabrian chile, hot honey, and spicy arrabbiata sauce. Trust me, this combo will have your taste buds dancing.

If you’re not into pizza bagels (How?), no worries. You can keep it simple with a bagel and schmear. Whether it’s a classic plain bagel or something more adventurous like cinnamon raisin or pumpernickel, they’ve got a schmear for you. Try roasted shallot cream cheese, labneh & spring herb cream cheese, or pesto cream cheese. And, of course, they’ve got the basics, too, like plain cream cheese and peanut butter (because bagels and peanut butter are yet another perfect pair).

Don’t stop there... if you’re in the mood for something more exciting, check out their bagel sandwiches. The Pastrami Chop Cheese is one of the most stacked bagel sandwiches you'll ever see, leaving you full for hours. Or indulge in the Smoke Whitefish Salad, a delightful blend of flavors perfect for a more sophisticated bite.

For the truly adventurous, bagel tartines are a must-try. My choice? The Chicken Liver Mousse Tartine, made with chicken liver mousse, chicken skin granola, bacon, and date molasses. It’s rich, flavorful, and absolutely delicious.

And if that’s not enough, Allie Boy’s also serves up Matzoh Ball Soup and the Big Latke Waffle. The latke waffle is crispy perfection, served with applesauce and sour cream—comfort food at its best.

And if you’re lucky enough to be there when they have their Mango Hot Flash Sauce in stock? Don’t leave without grabbing a bottle. It’s a sweet, spicy, tangy miracle that will make you want to drizzle it on everything.

Whether you're a local or just visiting, Allie Boy’s Bagelry & Luncheonette is the place for pizza bagels (and just bagels in general) done right. So next time you’re in Milwaukee, swing by, grab a bite, and see if there are any untapped Brew City experiences you could uncover!