America’s 13 Most Iconic Pie Shops and the Treats They’re Known For

Ever get that sudden, undeniable urge for a slice of really good pie? We get it! So, we set out on a mission: to find the best of the best, discovering 13 standout pie shops in the U.S. along the way.

More than mere pie shops, these are places where you can taste the region in every bite. Think juicy blueberries in Maine, spicy green chile in New Mexico, and everything in between. These aren't just bakeries; they're landmarks, each with a story to tell. Ready to dive into some seriously scrumptious pie?

Northeast

This region highlights deep-rooted recipes, from Maine’s berry-filled specialties to Pennsylvania’s molasses-kissed pastries and Vermont’s maple-infused treats. The Northwest is flush with delicious pies and baked goods, each so scrumptious, you'll want to try them all.

1. Two Fat Cats Bakery - Portland, Maine

Two Fat Cats Bakery is beloved for its Wild Maine Blueberry Pie, packed with locally sourced, tart-sweet blueberries and wrapped in a delicately flaky crust. This quintessential New England dessert celebrates Maine’s blueberry heritage, made fresh daily with care and top-notch ingredients. With two Portland locations, Two Fat Cats Bakery is a must-visit for pie lovers exploring the city—if you're not in Portland, you can also order it online for delivery throughout the U.S.

2. Dutch Haven - Ronks, Pennsylvania

Dutch Haven has been dishing up its renowned Shoo-Fly Pie since the 1940s. This sticky, molasses-sweet treat is a Pennsylvania Dutch staple, deeply tied to the area’s Amish culture. The shop itself, with its distinctive windmill design, is a roadside landmark and a regular stop for Lancaster County visitors.

3. Wayside Restaurant - Berlin, Vermont

For a true taste of Vermont, Wayside Restaurant’s Maple Cream Pie is a must. Made with the state’s signature maple syrup, this pie is smooth, custardy, and brimming with caramelized maple goodness. This family-run spot has been a community favorite since 1918, serving up comfort food in a cozy, old-school diner setting.

Midwest

Home to fruit-forward baking, the Midwest offers towering, fresh-from-the-orchard pies, heirloom recipes, and uniquely Midwestern pairings. From Missouri to Michigan, you'll uncover no shortage of spectacular desserts hiding in this stunning region.

4. Blue Owl Restaurant and Bakery - Kimmswick, Missouri

The Levee High Caramel Apple Pecan Pie at Blue Owl is a showstopper - a towering slice filled with layers of delicious apples, buttery crust, and decadent caramel drizzle. Created by Blue Owl, this legendary dessert honors Kimmswick's survival of the 1993 Great Flood. The bakery is a Midwest treasure, known for its over-the-top pies and small-town charm.

5. Kathy's Pies - Cedar Rapids, Iowa

Kathy’s Pies keeps an old-fashioned Iowa tradition alive with its Crust Raisin Pie. The filling, crafted from plump, succulent raisins, is tucked inside a flaky double crust, offering a nostalgic slice of Midwestern heritage. Locals swear by this classic dessert in addition to the number one seller, the chocolate cream pie. Both are highly recommended when passing through Cedar Rapids.

6. The Cherry Hut - Beulah, Michigan

Since 1922, The Cherry Hut has been delighting visitors with its Cherry Hut Cherry Pie, made with Michigan’s famous Montmorency cherries. Tangy and bursting with flavor, this pie is the highlight of summer visits to Beulah. The nostalgic, cherry red shop is as iconic as the dessert itself.

South

Comfort food is synonymous with the south, and what could be more comforting that a slice of sweet, homestyle pie? Southern baking blends warm spices, buttery crusts, and inventive takes on heritage recipes, from sweet potato perfection to caramel-laced indulgences.

7. Royers Round Top Café - Round Top, Texas

Royers Round Top Café is the birthplace of Texas Trash Pie, a sweet-and-salty mix of chocolate chips, coconut, graham crackers, caramel, and pretzels. This quirky, small-town bistro is known for bold flavors, a friendly atmosphere, and a menu that goes beyond the expected. Despite Round Top’s tiny population, Royers has gained a nationwide following, making it a destination pie aficionados shouldn’t miss.

8. Georgia's Sweet Potato Pie Company - Louisville, Kentucky

Sweet potato pie is a Southern favorite, and this Louisville gem perfects it with scratch-made pies using top-quality ingredients like real butter and vanilla. Their Traditional Sweet Potato Pie is creamy, lightly spiced, and incredibly smooth. This inviting, family-owned shop doesn’t just bake tasty pies, they give back to the community with every slice, making each bite even sweeter.

9. Miss Angel's Heavenly Pies - Mount Airy, North Carolina

Miss Angel's puts a twist on the traditional Surry County Sonker with its one-of-a-kind Zonker. Baked with seasonal fruits soaked in moonshine and honey from their farm, this deep-dish dessert offers a warm, comforting taste of North Carolina with a spirited kick. Located in Andy Griffith’s hometown, this charming bakery blends local tradition with innovation.

Southwest

While for many, the Southwest conjures images of enchiladas and chimichangas, this is far from the only fare this region is known for. Sensational desserts abound in the American Southwest. Here, unexpected combinations take center stage, where chile-infused fillings, nutty textures, and cactus-derived flavors redefine dessert.

10. The Range Café - Bernalillo, New Mexico

The Green Chile Apple Pie at The Range Café offers an original spin on a familiar recipe, featuring crisp apples mixed with roasted green chiles and crunchy pine nuts. This unexpected combination perfectly represents New Mexico’s unique tastes. With several locations and a laid-back, Southwestern-style vibe, this café is a regional favorite.

11. Margie's Kitchen - Tucson, Arizona

Margie’s Kitchen brings the Southwest to life with its Prickly Pear Meringue Pie, made from the bold magenta fruit of the desert cactus. The flavor is refreshing, slightly tangy, and totally satisfying. This local breakfast favorite in Tucson serves up homestyle comfort food with a distinctly Arizona flair.

Northwest

Lush berry harvests shape the Northwest’s signature treats, where marionberries, blackberries, and raspberries add a burst of vibrant, seasonal goodness. In some cases, these bright berries complement flavors like rhubarb. Other times they stand on their own as the centerpiece to fresh-baked desserts. All are entirely delicious to try.

12. Snohomish Pie Company - Snohomish, Washington

Snohomish Pie Company's Raspberry Rhubarb Pie wonderfully captures the Pacific Northwest’s seasonal bounty. Available from June through Labor Day, this pie combines the bright tartness of fresh raspberries with the tanginess of rhubarb, all topped with a golden, buttery brown sugar oat crumble. It’s a delicious balance of flavors, made with the region’s finest ingredients. The cozy bakeshop, with two Washington locations, has a welcoming, hometown feel that's hard to resist.

13. Willamette Valley Pie Company - Salem, Oregon

Oregon’s prized marionberries shine in Willamette Valley Pie Company’s signature Marionberry Pie. The deep-purple berries bring a rich earthiness to the filling, beautifully complemented by the buttery, flaky crust. The company, rooted in local berry farming traditions, offers a farm-fresh experience for visitors looking to taste Oregon’s best.

From coast to coast, our pie adventure has shown us that true baking magic lies in regional flavors and heartfelt traditions. These 13 shops aren't just serving dessert; they're offering a taste of home, a slice of local culture. So, whether you're a seasoned pie enthusiast or simply seeking a sweet escape, these destinations are your guide to discovering America's most delicious regional treasures.

Do you have a favorite pie shop in the U.S. that we missed? Let us know by submitting a nomination! And for more delicious travel inspiration, don’t miss these 12 mouthwatering destinations across the U.S. If you’re ready to check the first spot off your list, use the Only In Your State itinerary planner to help you curate the perfect trip!