This 136-Year Old Steakhouse Is One Of The Most Nostalgic Destinations In New York

If a restaurant has been in business for 136 years, they have probably been doing something right. If they are also widely known as one of the best steakhouses in America, then they have definitely been doing something right. We are talking about Peter Luger, a Brooklyn steakhouse that is many cuts above the rest, and one of the most iconic places to eat in America. A trip to Peter Luger is an exciting and definitely nostalgic way to explore how dining used to be—and still can be. We think it's the best steakhouse in New York City. To learn more, keep reading, below.

Peter Luger is situated in the Williamsburg neighborhood of Brooklyn, with additional outposts in Great Neck, New York, Tokyo, Japan and Las Vegas. It’s the third oldest steakhouse in New York City that continues to be in operation.

The Brooklyn location, which we will be focusing on here, was created in 1887 under the name Carl Luger's Café, Billiards and Bowling Alley. In 1950, Peter Luger’s son Frederick auctioned off the restaurant to new owners, Solo Forman and Seymour Sloyer, who have kept it in the family since.

The menu at Peter Luger is focused on steakhouse classics, in particular their porterhouse steak, which is sized for two or four diners. It comes to the table sizzling.

Then there are those classic sides! Don’t forget the creamed spinach. We also recommend the thick bacon.

The atmosphere at Peter Luger, with its wood and chandeliers, will take diners to another era entirely.

To eat at Peter Luger, visitors must secure a reservation. But, trust us, it's well worth the effort. The restaurant is truly old school: no credit cards allowed!

Peter Luger is part of the prestigious James Beard Award's list of "America's Classic" restaurants, and for a good reason. In it's combination of amazing food and a historic atmosphere, it is truly an unforgettable experience.

For a timeless meal with flavors that never go out of style, it's worth making a reservation to go and eat at Peter Luger in Brooklyn, the best steakhouse in New York City. While in Brooklyn, why not also check out Brooklyn Flea, which we think is the best flea market in New York City. And, for those looking for a place to stay near Peter Luger, we recommend Moxy Brooklyn Williamsburg.