St. Elmo Steak House is a historic and quaint Indiana restaurant that’s been around since 1902. It has remained in its current location ever since. This is one of the oldest restaurants in Indiana and does its best to preserve its old-fashioned style and ambiance. Throughout the years, this has been the place where politicians and tycoons negotiated their dealings, coaches, and players of sports teams celebrated their victories and washed away their defeats, and celebrities came to dine in style.
This old building is instantly recognizable to anyone who grew up in Indianapolis. When the Circle Center Mall opened nearby in 1996, the restaurant did a multi-million dollar makeover but kept most of the old-style charm.
The classic wooden interior looks much like it did in its earlier days, but with more modern, comfortable furnishings. When you sit down here, you know you’re in for a treat.
The shrimp cocktail is almost as famous as the steaks. It has four jumbo shrimp with an original, house-made spicy cocktail sauce and slices of fresh lemon. This appetizer is a beloved local favorite.
The ribeye steak is well-marbled and cooked to perfection. St. Elmo’s also serves a porterhouse, filet mignon, USDA Prime New York strip steak, a classic flat iron steak, and prime dry-aged steaks.
Another favorite here is the pork chops, which are locally sourced and cherrywood smoked, served with redskin mashed potatoes, and sweet cinnamon apple slices.
The seafood is as top-notch as the steaks and chops, with fresh, seasonal selections at market prices. The main attractions are the Sashimi Yellowfin Tuna, Cold Water Lobster Tail, Crab Stuffed Shrimp, and Seafood Pasta.
The delectable desserts here are to die for and so very rich. This Double Chocolate Mousse Pie includes raspberry puree, espresso cream anglaise, and candied toffee crumbs. There’s also a decadent White Chocolate Blueberry Bread Pudding, a Bourbon Butter Cake, a signature Crème Brulee, and more!
Harry Roth and Isadore Rosen ran this steak house from 1947 to 1986 before passing it on to current owner Stephen Huse. St. Elmo Steak House is extremely popular, so you’ll certainly want to make reservations. Have you been to St. Elmo’s Steak House before? If so, please let us know all about it in the comments. This restaurant is one of the things that makes Indianapolis perhaps the most unique city in America.
Subscribe to our newsletter
Get the latest updates and news
Thank you for subscribing!