First thing first - Florida is a massive state, so while we wish we could tackle all of the very best pizza places in one road trip, that would probably take you at least a handful of months to complete. So, for this ultimate pizza journey in Florida, we decided to keep it all within reason in one region of the state. With that said, buckle up for one of the tastiest, cheesiest, tomato-iest road trips you’ve ever taken, with each locale offering up scrumptious pizza like you haven’t had before.
The entire pizza journey in Florida takes about 4.5 hours to complete in terms of travel time, but you’ll want to carve out more time to stop and sink your teeth into a slice or two. You can find the entire pizza trip itinerary here.
1. Eddie & Sam’s New York Pizza - Tampa
Eddie & Sam’s New York Pizza is the perfect first stop on this road trip list. To start, they serve thin-crust pizza either by the slice or the pie, so you can start off easy. But what many people might not know is that this pizza dough is made from New York water, which is likely a major reason why it’s got over 6,000 nearly five-star reviews.
Click here to learn more about this Florida pizza spot.
2. Toby’s Original Little Italy Pizza - St. Petersburg
Toby’s Original Little Italy Pizza in St. Petersburg is a straightforward pizzeria serving up huge pies, garlic knots, subs, and more. Open since 1972, Toby’s has offered patrons true New York-style pies and subs seven days a week. Don’t miss out on this St. Pete classic.
Click here to learn more about this Florida pizza spot.
3. Lazy Moon - Orlando
Lazy Moon pizza is a coveted spot in Orlando serving up some of the best pizza around. First and foremost, this pizza is not only tasty but also features a bevy of unique flavors and toppings. But what really makes Lazy Moon shine are the GIANT pies they offer. Perfect for a party or just a really lazy weekend in, you’ll want to get your hands on these gargantuan pizzas.
Click here to learn more about this Florida pizza spot.
4. Pizza Xtreme - Orlando
Don’t let the setting fool you, this basic strip mall joint is bursting with pizza flavor and innovation. To start, you’ll be given the option to create your own pies, so that alone is worth the trip. But also, simply by word of mouth, this pizza shop has risen in the ranks to become one of the best-hidden gems in Orlando.
Click here to learn more about this Florida pizza spot.
5. NYPD Pizza at Lake Cay - Orlando
If you’re looking to feast on true New York-style pizza, then why not go straight to the source?! NYPD Pizza offers pizza pies that are 30 percent bigger than chain competitors, plus a featured slice of the day. After a native New Yorker couldn’t find a good pizza in Florida over 20 years ago, NYPD Pizza in Lake Cay was opened and has been slinging pies ever since.
Click here to learn more about this Florida pizza spot.
6. Alberto's Pizzeria Italian Restaurant - Edgewater
We head over to Alberto’s Pizzeria Italian Restaurant in Edgewater, Florida for our next stop, which has been open since 1956. Order up a whole pie and a Stromboli for the family, or just get a slice and keep moving. But with an interior that will feel like your Italian family member’s house, you might just want to order a glass of chianti and get to know the locals.
Click here to learn more about this Florida pizza spot.
7. Genovese’s Italian Cafe - Ormond Beach
Genovese’s Italian Cafe might read as a small strip mall spot, but they’ve been heralded as having some of the best pizza and Stromboli in the area. With a crispy crust and soft dough, you can order up a pie to your liking every time. Just prepare yourself for a crowd, the locals here love this pizza!
Click here to learn more about this Florida pizza spot.
So, what do you think about this pizza journey in Florida? Will you be making the trek? Share with us your thoughts in the comments section! Or if you have more pizza spots that you think deserve a chance, then shout those out, too!
Subscribe to our newsletter
Get the latest updates and news
Thank you for subscribing!
