When looking for a great place to dine in the Nutmeg State, it’s tempting to go with a place that’s eye-catching. We’re naturally drawn to places that are bold, with stupendous views, or flashy exteriors. Though they’re often delicious, concentrating on these types of places will have you ignoring many of our more humble, unassuming restaurants in Connecticut that also serve up incredible meals. One recent reader nomination fits into that category splendidly: Sarah’s On Main in Portland. This cozy little spot doesn’t look like much from the outside, but we think it serves a stellar breakfast and lunch.

Related Stories

You Can Enjoy Breakfast All Day Long At This Old School Eatery In Connecticut

You Can Enjoy Breakfast All Day Long At This Old School Eatery In Connecticut

The Best Breakfast In Connecticut Is Hiding In This Charming Small Town, And It's So Worth The Effort To Find It

The Best Breakfast In Connecticut Is Hiding In This Charming Small Town, And It's So Worth The Effort To Find It

This Old-School Connecticut Restaurant Serves Breakfast To Die For

This Old-School Connecticut Restaurant Serves Breakfast To Die For

For more information about Sarah’s on Main in Connecticut, including a menu and hours of operation, check out the Facebook page of Sarah’s on Main. While you’re in the Portland area, consider driving about two miles southwest for a memorable night’s stay at the Inn at Middletown – a historic colonial-style hotel in the area.

This delicious restaurant was nominated to us by readers like you! If you’d like to see your favorite restaurant or attraction featured in a future article, get in touch with us via our nominations page, and let us know your favorite unassuming restaurants in Connecticut in the comments section!

OnlyInYourState may earn compensation through affiliate links in this article. As an Amazon Associate, we earn from qualifying purchases.

More to Explore

Unassuming Restaurants In Connecticut

What Are The Best Unassuming Restaurants In Connecticut?

These four hidden gems are worth the drive from anywhere in the state!

  • Falafel Taco, a fast-casual restaurant in Greenwich, offers something rare - a type of cuisine you probably haven't tasted before! This is a Mexican-Israeli fusion restaurant, serving up tacos and bowls packed with shawarma, schnitzel, and falafel with sides that include intensely flavored salads and the spherical pasta called Israeli couscous. The Greenwich location is Kosher-certified, and this is a great place for adventurous eaters.
  • Bereket Turkish Restaurant might just be the best-hidden restaurant in all of Connecticut - you can find it in a gas station in Bridgeport! But this is no casual gas-station snack - Bereket serves up a full menu of Turkish delights. Start with some coffee, then move on to a hearty plate of kebabs, pita, and salad before finishing off with some of the best baklava in the state. This is the kind of place only a few people know about - but they're the lucky ones!
  • The Pantry in Washington Depot has been a Connecticut staple for a very long time - since 1977 - and this casual cafe has a very loyal audience. It's not just a restaurant - it also doubles as a country store, selling gifts and kitchen supplies. But you'll definitely want to stick around for the food. This is a great spot for a light meal, which changes by the day. Fish tacos, salads, and fresh-baked desserts may show up on the menu here.
  • Blue Plate Kitchen, located in West Hartford, might just be our favorite spot for southern food in Connecticut. This casual diner-style restaurant serves all three meals, but it's breakfast that really takes the starring role here. This place serves the best biscuits and gravy in Connecticut, as well as delicious omelets. When it comes to later meals, the chicken pot pie is a big favorite among locals.

Explore Connecticut