Everyone has heard of the famous Loch Ness monster and the various sea monsters some people think inhabit the world’s oceans. You may not know, however, that Nebraska has its very own lake monster known as the Alkali Lake Monster…a huge, stinky creature blamed for eating livestock and anything else in its path.

Google Maps
Near Hay Springs in northwestern Nebraska lies a smallish body of water once known as Alkali Lake (today it goes by Walgren Lake.) Legend has it that the lake is home to a terrifying aquatic animal known as the Alkali Lake Monster (or sometimes the Walgren Lake Monster.) The beast is said to be anywhere from 40 to 100 feet in length, somewhat resembling an alligator. Some depictions give the monster four legs, while others show it with two front legs and a flipper in the back. Still others give it the serpentine body most often associated with the Loch Ness monster. Most depictions agree that the beast has a large horn between its eyes and a horrible, unforgettable stench.
Wikimedia Commons - Unknown author - The New Student's Reference Work, v. 4, 1914, p. 1664
While some people have claimed that sightings of the monster can be traced back to Native American legends, the first written record of the monster is from a 1922 issue of the Hay Springs News. The following year, a local man named J.A. Johnson described the monster in an interview with the Omaha World Herald. Johnson and two of his friends were camping on the banks of the lake when they noticed the creature about 60 feet away. The men claimed that as soon as the beast saw them, it belted out a huge roar, whipped around, and plunged beneath the muddy lake water.

Related Stories

The Nebraska Ghost Story That Will Leave You Absolutely Baffled

The Nebraska Ghost Story That Will Leave You Absolutely Baffled

 Driving Down This Haunted Nebraska Road Will Give You Nightmares

Driving Down This Haunted Nebraska Road Will Give You Nightmares

 Hummel Park Might Just Be The Most Haunted Park In Nebraska

Hummel Park Might Just Be The Most Haunted Park In Nebraska
History Nebraska
History Nebraska
Still, the people in and around Hay Springs aren’t in any hurry to let go of the story. They commemorated the tall tale during the town’s centennial celebration in 1985, selling shirts and buttons with the monster’s likeness on them. The beast is something of a source of pride for the little town; it was even mentioned in the classic novel Old Jules by Nebraska author Mari Sandoz. Sandoz also based her short story "Ossie and the Sea Monster" on the tale of the Nebraska Alkali Lake Monster.

If you visit the lake and happen to see – or smell – the legendary Walgren Lake Monster, share your story in the comments! Also, if you know of any other urban legends in Nebraska, tell us about them on our nomination form for the chance to see them featured in an upcoming article.

OnlyInYourState may earn compensation through affiliate links in this article. As an Amazon Associate, we earn from qualifying purchases.

More to Explore

Urban Legends In Nebraska & Related Info

Katie Lawrence | January 02, 2023

Besides the Alkali Lake Monster, what are some of the scariest urban legends in Nebraska?

Some of the scariest urban legends in Nebraska include:

  • Radioactive, mutated hornets

In 2013, there was a (false) rumor that hornets exposed to radiation from the Fukushima Daiichi nuclear disaster had reached Nebraska.

This infamous murder-suicide legend tells the story of a young woman whose husband stabs her to death after hearing that she still has feelings for her ex-lover.

  • Febold Feboldson, Drought Buster Extraordinaire

As this legend goes, a man named Febold Feboldson brought an end to a historic Nebraska drought by setting fires around lakes to evaporate all of the water so that it could come back down in the form of rain.

  • The Hatchet House

This gruesome legend takes place in the town of Portal, where a schoolteacher allegedly killed all of her students and placed their hearts underneath a nearby bridge.

  • Weeping Water

Located in Cass County, the town of Weeping Water is named after a creek that derives its name from a Native American tribal battle so bloody, the women created a brand new body of water with their tears.

Does Nebraska have any ghost stories?

Nebraska has several ghost stories, including:

  • The Alliance Theater, Alliance

Originally a hotel, the Alliance Theater is a paranormal hotspot. Employees have reported seeing shadowy figures and hearing disembodied footsteps.

  • Antelope Park, Lincoln

Visitors have seen apparitions floating through a field behind the caretaker's house at Antelope Park in Lincoln.

  • Ball Cemetery, Springfield

One of the most haunted cemeteries in Nebraska, Ball Cemetery has its fair share of ghost stories. Those brave enough to visit have spotted a male apparition and heard the voice of a female who is nowhere to be found.

 

Related Articles

Explore Nebraska

Featured Addresses
Walgren Lake, Hay Springs, NE 69347, USA