menu search

Posted in West Virginia Food & Dining, Hidden Gems September 13, 2017 by Catherine Armstrong

After Just One Bite You’ll Be Hooked On The Sandwiches At This Amazing Restaurant In West Virginia

We can’t praise the sandwich enough: it’s portable, versatile and oh-so-good no matter what you put on it. Here’s a little sandwich shop in Fayetteville that will keep you coming back for more.

The Secret Sandwich Society is no secret to the residents of Fayetteville. This place has been serving up gourmet sandwiches since 2010.

You'll love the laid-back vibe of this cool little sandwich shop.

The sandwiches here are all named for former Presidents, and each is as unique as its namesake.

Try the Eisenhower: Mortadella ham, cherry peppers, provolone, garlic mayo and red wine vinaigrette.

The Taft comes with tender pork shoulder, rosemary mayo, braised kale and provolone.

The Hoover includes a fried chicken breast, pickles, greens, honey butter and Swiss cheese.

You must have a side order of Pimiento Cheese Fries.

House made Society Chips are sprinkled with Society Magic Powder (yes, that's really what they call it), and they're delicious.

Pair a tasty craft beer with your sandwich.

Dine on the deck when the weather is nice.

Visit the Secret Sandwich Society Wednesday through Monday from 11 AM to 10 PM. The shop is closed on Tuesday.

Looking for more great eats in West Virginia? Check out these 13 places you have to eat before you die.

OnlyInYourState may earn compensation through affiliate links in this article.

Catherine Armstrong

Writer, editor and researcher with a passion for exploring new places. Catherine loves local bookstores, independent films, and spending time with her family, including Gus the golden retriever, who is a very good boy.