There are two types of Rhode Islanders: those who start to think about Halloween in late October, and those who deck their homes out in spooky decor and start planning their costumes in early September. But both types can definitely appreciate a good ghost story, especially as All Hallow’s Eve draws near. If you grew up in the Ocean State, you’ve probably heard the sinister story of Mercy Brown — and you may already know that Chestnut Hill Cemetery is a spooky place.

Chestnut Hill Baptist Church Cemetery is located in Exeter.
Matt / Flickr
The cemetery dates back to the 1830s, and the onsite church was added to the National Register of Historic Places in 1978.
The cemetery is a bit hidden, and if you didn't know any better, you'd think it was pretty peaceful.
Brenna Pinot / Google
But after dark, it's definitely a spooky place to be.
The Chestnut Hill Cemetery is the final resting place of the Brown family, the main characters in one of New England's sinister stories.
Matt / Flickr
Given the family's unfortunate history, it's easy to understand why being here feels a bit unsettling.

Related Stories

With A Kid-Friendly Menu, This Incredible Restaurant In Rhode Island Is Perfect For Families

With A Kid-Friendly Menu, This Incredible Restaurant In Rhode Island Is Perfect For Families

 Escape To The Countryside When You Stay At This Rural Airbnb In Rhode Island

Escape To The Countryside When You Stay At This Rural Airbnb In Rhode Island

 You'll Never Look At Donuts The Same Way After Trying Daily RI Homemade Donuts In Rhode Island

You'll Never Look At Donuts The Same Way After Trying Daily RI Homemade Donuts In Rhode Island
In the 1880s, the entire Brown family contracted consumption, which we now know to be tuberculosis.
Josh McGinn / Flickr
Mary Eliza, the mother, was the first to die of the disease. Her daughter, Mary Olive, died soon after.
But when the Mercy Brown died of tuberculosis in 1891, and her brother Edwin also got sick, the community started to suspect foul play.
Brenna Pinto / Google
There were rumors that one of the dead family members was actually a vampire. The bodies of all three women were exhumed for inspection.
The bodies of Mary and Mary Olive exhibited the expected level of decomposition, but Mercy's body was still almost perfectly preserved, and she still had blood in her heart.
Matt / Flickr
Mercy's body was stored in freezer-like conditions in an above-ground crypt for two months following her death, which is probably why her body was preserved. Of course, the townsfolk determined that she was a vampire — and, in a desperate attempt to save his son Edwin, father George Brown allowed Mercy's heart and liver to be burned and turned into an elixir for Edwin to drink. Sadly, Edwin died anyway.
With a tale that gruesome, it's easy to see why Mercy Brown may not be resting in peace.
Elizabethe / Flickr
The Brown family's remains are still here, and if you go to see them, you may want to do it before it gets dark.

Have you ever visited this spooky cemetery?

OnlyInYourState may earn compensation through affiliate links in this article. As an Amazon Associate, we earn from qualifying purchases.

Related Articles

Featured Addresses
Chestnut Hill Baptist Church Cemetery, Exeter, RI 02822, USA