Have you ever had tomato pie? Whether you have or you haven’t, you simply must stop by Napoli’s Italian Bakery and Deli in Utica and get yourself a pie or a slice. This is the best tomato pie in Utica and perhaps all of New York. And we know you’re going to love it, too. Read on to learn more about this iconic pizza restaurant that all the Utica locals adore. Soon, you’ll be in on the big secret, and you’ll adore the tasty tomato pie as well!

Related Stories

Enjoy Fair Foods Almost Year Round At This Unique New York Restaurant

Enjoy Fair Foods Almost Year Round At This Unique New York Restaurant

The BBQ At This New York Restaurant Is So Good That It Sells Out Every Day

The BBQ At This New York Restaurant Is So Good That It Sells Out Every Day

If Pasta Is Your Love Language, You'll Be In Heaven At Ca’Mea Ristorante In New York

If Pasta Is Your Love Language, You'll Be In Heaven At Ca’Mea Ristorante In New York

Tomato pie is deliciously fantastic, and nobody does it better than Napoli’s Italian Bakery! Next time you’re in Utica, be sure to stop by. They’ve got the best tomato pie in New York and this iconic food is something that everyone loves!

Looking for more iconic foods in New York? Check out this list for more: These 14 Iconic Foods In New York Will Have Your Mouth Watering.

These 14 Iconic Foods In New York Will Have Your Mouth Watering

And for the real foodies, check out these food tours in New York, where you can eat through the menus of some of the best restaurants in the state.

OnlyInYourState may earn compensation through affiliate links in this article. As an Amazon Associate, we earn from qualifying purchases.

More to Explore

Iconic Foods In New York

Where can I find the best pizza in New York?
While Napoli’s serves what we believe to be the best tomato pie in New York, if you prefer a traditional pie, here are some of the restaurants with the best pizza in New York:

  • Bleecker Street Pizza, New York City
  • Andriaccio’s, Mayville
  • Tino's Pizza, Oneonta
  • DeFazio's Pizzeria, Troy
  • Emiliano Pizza, Poughkeepsie
  • Joe's Pizza Broadway, New York City
  • Kay's Pizza (Temporarily Closed), Averill Park
  • O’Scugnizzo Pizzeria, Utica
  • Aniello’s Pizzeria, Corning
  • Sal's Pizzeria, Mamaroneck
  • Elm Street Bakery, East Aurora
  • The Pizza Stop, Rochester

Be sure to check out our previous article to learn more about the restaurants with the best pizza in New York. Or check out our website featuring more iconic NY pizza restaurants

What are some of the best Italian restaurants in New York?

If you love everything about pasta and Italian food, here are the best Italian restaurants in New York that belong on your list:

  • Verdile’s Restaurant, Troy
  • Pastabilities, Syracuse
  • DeStefano’s Olde Erie, Middletown
  • Ilio DiPaolo’s Restaurant - Blasdell
  • Via Carota, New York City
  • Rosalie's Cucina - Skaneateles
  • Chianti II Ristorante - Saratoga Springs
  • Rubirosa, New York City
  • Casa De Pasta - Canandaigua
  • Chef's Restaurant, Buffalo
  • Roberto's, Bronx
  • OLIO E PIÙ, New York City

Here’s an article telling you more about the best Italian restaurants in New York

Besides pizza, what are some more iconic foods in New York?

It’s no secret that New Yorkers love pizza, but here are some more iconic foods that we also love:

  • Nathan's Hot Dogs
  • Chicken Wings
  • New York Cheesecake
  • Garbage Plate
  • Chicken Riggies
  • Beef on Weck
  • Peppermint Pig
  • Saratoga Chips
  • Spiedie
  • Sponge Candy

Wanna know more about these foods? Read our article about these iconic foods in New York.

Explore New York