10 Stores In Indiana To Buy The Best Sugar Cream Pie For Your Thanksgiving Celebration
Every Hoosier knows you simply can’t have Thanksgiving without an incredible sugar cream pie. While homemade pies are always the best, sometimes with everything else going on, you don’t have the time to whip one up from scratch. If you’re feeling the heat, grab a highly rated sugar cream pie from one of these 10 amazing Hoosier restaurants.
1. Storie's Restaurant - Greenburg
The pies at Storie's are legendary and extensive. These homemade pies range from flavors such as apple crumb, banana cream, and cherry to, of course, sugar cream pie.
Find them at 109 E Main St, Greensburg, IN 47240.
2. Nordmann’s Nook – North Manchester
This eclectic little bakery is actually housed inside of a local furniture store. Don't be misled, though; they have some of the best pies around. And their Hoosier cream pie can be purchased for under 10 bucks!
Find them at 1106 IN-114, North Manchester, IN 46962.
3. Mrs. Wick's Pie - Winchester
Mrs. Wick's is definitely one of the most famous places in the state to grab an incredible sugar cream pie. Many claim that Wick's sugar cream pies are the pies to beat!
Try them at 100 Cherry St, Winchester, IN 47394.
4. Bob's Restaurant - Woodburn
Anyone near Woodburn knows that Bob's is the place for great pies. This locally owned restaurant offers great breakfast, but is most famous for their pies made entirely from scratch, including, of course, sugar cream pie.
Find them at 22031 Main St, Woodburn, IN 46797.
5. Lisa's Pie Shop - Atlanta
With a name like Lisa's Pie Shop, you know you'll be getting some pretty amazing pies. This little shop is well known for their pies in a jar, as well as their award winning sugar cream pie.
Find them at 5995 S Us Hwy 31, Atlanta, IN 46031
6. Bruner's Family Restaurant - Muncie
This local establishment in Muncie has an amazing bakery case packed full of delicious sweets. Their sugar cream pie is one of the best desserts you can get here.
Try it at 2200 W Kilgore Ave, Muncie, IN 47304.
7. Nick's Kitchen - Huntington
Nick's is famous for their Hoosier tenderloins, but many people also travel for miles just to sample a bite of their outstanding sugar cream pie.
Try it at 506 N Jefferson St, Huntington, IN 46750.
8. Marilyn's Bakery - Hobart
This tiny bakery draws people from all around the state. Their pastries and desserts are simply out of this world and their pies are all homemade and simply incredible! You have to try this sugar cream pie at least once in your life!
Try it at 8960 E Ridge Rd, Hobart, IN 46342.
9. The Bluebird Restaurant - Morristown
The Bluebird might be an awesome stop for dinner, but it's also the perfect place to pick up a sugar cream pie, and other desserts.
Try it at 158 E Main St
10. Tiffany's Restaurant - Topeka
Deep in the heart of Amish Country, Indiana, you'll find this charming family restaurant. The food is delicious, but the homemade pies are out of this world good.
Try them at 414 E Lake St, Topeka, IN 46761.
Have you tried any of these famous sugar cream pies in Indiana? For more great desserts in the Hoosier state, check out this
OnlyInYourState may earn compensation through affiliate links in this article. As an Amazon Associate, we earn from qualifying purchases.