7 Amish Bakeries In Indiana With Treats Better Than Grandma Makes
×
Elizabeth Crozier
Author
It is probably not a surprise that Indiana is home to several amazing Amish bakeries. These shops are known for homemade breads and pastries that are better than any others in the Midwest. For a taste of true handmade fare, check out these seven amazing bakeries.
This amazing little bakery is known for its award-winning donuts as well as other fantastic sweets like cinnamon rolls, cookies, and fresh bread. It was opened in 2015 by a woman whose father was Amish, so you know the goodies are legitimate. Try something delicious at 62 N 1st St., Zionsville, IN 46077.
Advertisement
Advertisement
This amazing place is more than just one of the best Amish bakeries in the Hoosier State. It is also a hotel, a restaurant, and an event venue. The best sweets to get are the whoopie pies, sweet rolls, and fry pies. Find all this and much more at 240 Hwy 20, Middlebury, IN 46540.
Yet another fun-filled Amish-themed attraction, this little village has more than just a great bakery. It also houses a restaurant, shops, and guestrooms, and there is often live entertainment to enjoy. The bakery is full of treats like cakes, rolls, bars, pies, and more. Find it at 6747 E Gasthof Village Rd., Montgomery, IN 47558.
Related Stories
8 Ice Cream Stands In Indiana That Are So Small You'll Have To Take Your Treat To Go
This Old World Bakery In Indiana Sells The Best Amish Donuts In The State
This Award-Winning Donut Bakery In Indiana Is Known For Its Old-Fashioned Ways
This tiny, small town bakery does homemade, Amish-style baked goods that can't be beat. From pies to breads to dumplings, this fantastic shop does it all. Check it out at 8260 IN-15, Claypool, IN 46510.
Advertisement
This is the most popular of all Amish bakeries in the state. It is best known for a cinnamon caramel donut. In addition to baked goods, guests can also get lunch items and hand-dipped ice cream treats at one of its nine locations in Indiana. Learn more about these wonderful shops here.
The Amish-made goods at this store are such delicious treats, they make excellent gifts. In addition to incredible cookies, breads, cake rolls, and whoopie pies, this shop also sells homemade popcorn, jams and jellies, as well as lunch items like sandwiches, wraps, soups, and salads. Spend the afternoon at 120 N Morton St., Shipshewana, IN 46565.
Advertisement
In business since 1924, this amazing bakery is not quite Amish, but it is Dutch. The original owner immigrated to the United States in 1914 to work in the bakery at Notre Dame before opening this place under the name "Purity Bakery." Guests enjoy cookies, cakes, hand-cut doughnuts, danish, eclairs, and more. It is located at 508 W Lincoln Ave., Goshen, IN 46526.
For more like this, check out nine donut shops in Indiana that will drive you wild.
What other Amish bakeries do you enjoy? Share your favorites with us below in the comments.
OnlyInYourState may earn compensation through affiliate links in this article. As an Amazon Associate, we earn from qualifying purchases.