The Pie Recipes At Troyer’s Home Pantry In Ohio Are A Best Kept Family Secret

There's nothing like a hearty slice of freshly baked pie. Troyer's Home Pantry in both Apple Creek and Wooster, Ohio is a longtime family-owned and operated bakery that's truly mastered the art of pie baking. The next time you're craving a fruit pie or some other type of freshly baked dessert, consider stopping by this legendary pastry and coffee shop.

For more than 40 years, Troyer's Home Pantry has specialized in tried and true pie recipes and other fresh baked goods.

Note: There are two locations of Troyer's Home Pantry. Pantry 1 (pictured) is in Apple Creek and Pantry 2 is in Wooster.

The pies here are life-changing. Baked to perfection with irresistible fillings, you'll want to try them all.

The Fruit Pies are particularly popular here, but the Strawberry Pie and Cream Pies are just as divine.

From classics like cherry and apple to rhubarb and custard flavors, there's something here for every pie lover.

Whole pies range in price from $7.75 - $9.25. Pie specials for $6.75 are often available.

Maybe you're not in the mood for pie. (Crazy, right? But it happens.) No worries. Take some time to check out the homemade donuts, cookies, cupcakes, breads and more.

To view a full menu of all the baked goods, visit Troyer's Home Pantry's website.

Nothing pairs better with homemade sweets than a cup pf perfectly brewed coffee. Fortunately, that's always an option here.

Please note: Pantry 2 is closed on both Sundays and Mondays. Pantry 1 is closed on Sundays as well.

If you don't have the time to dine in, consider ordering carry-out or using the drive-thru service at Pantry 2. For more information, you can call (330) 698-4182.

To stay up to date on specials, hours of operation and more, follow Troyer's Home Pantry on Facebook.

Have you ever had a slice of pie from Troyer's Home Pantry before? If so, what's your favorite flavor? Share your thoughts and recommendations with us!

For more scrumptious pies and baked goods in Ohio, check out our previous articles: There’s A Bakery On This Beautiful Farm In Ohio And You Have To Visit and The World’s Best Pumpkin Donuts Are Made Daily Inside This Humble Little Ohio Bakery.