The Overstuffed Sandwiches From This Indiana Deli Are the Stuff of Dreams

Indianapolis might not be the first place that comes to mind when you’re dreaming of world-class food cities, but the truth is, it’s quietly becoming one. From breaded pork tenderloins to inventive craft beers, this city knows how to satisfy all your cravings. And if you’re looking to add a little more flavor to your Indy experience, there’s one place that’ll take your taste buds straight to Pennsylvania: Hoagies and Hops.

Now, you may be wondering… Pennsylvania, are they famous for sandwiches? And the answer is "Yes!" - especially for those who grew up there, like the owner of Hoagies and Hops.

What makes a sub good enough to carry the "Pennsylvania Style" moniker? First, the bread is straight from South Jersey, with that signature softness and chew that only a true hoagie roll can have. It’s more than just the bread, though; this place goes all in with the ingredients too. The meats, pickles, and chips? They’re shipped right from Philadelphia and the heart of Pennsylvania Dutch Country. It’s all about delivering that southeast Pennsylvania comfort food to Indianapolis, one sandwich at a time.

Located on the west side of Indy, Hoagies and Hops feels like a secret you’re lucky to discover. It’s a no-frills spot where the food does the talking (with a strong Pennsylvania accent, of course). The vibe is laid back, with regulars ordering their usuals and newcomers curiously scanning the menu. Whether you're in for a quick bite or a relaxed meal, it’s the kind of place you’ll want to return to time and again.

Let’s get into the sandwiches. At Hoagies and Hops, it's not just about making hoagies - it's about elevating them. Take the “Always Sunny,” for instance. It’s got everything you never knew you needed: crispy bacon bits, D&W turkey, smooth muenster cheese, and a zingy combo of horseradish mayo, banana peppers, and peppadew peppers, all topped with fresh lettuce and tomato. It's bold, tangy, and just spicy enough.

Then there’s the "Hog Island," a sandwich that’s not for the faint of heart. It packs a punch with layers of D&W Black Forest ham, salami, prosciutto, and capicola, topped with provolone, lettuce, tomato, onions, and a dash of oil and vinegar. It’s a true meat lover's dream.

For something with a little more kick, try the "Lions Den" - inspired by Penn State football, it’s packed with grilled chicken, hot capicola, fried onions, Cooper cheese, and a spicy sauce that’ll have your taste buds doing a happy dance. If you’re craving a little heat and a lot of flavor, this one’s your winner. Each bite is a mix of smoky, salty, and spicy perfection - trust us, it’s a hoagie that’ll make you roar.

But here’s where things get interesting: Hoagies and Hops gives you the option to swap out the bread entirely. At this Indiana deli, you can ask for your hoagie on a pickle. Yes, a pickle. The tangy crunch of the pickle perfectly complements the savory flavors of the hoagie, creating a whole new sandwich experience. It’s not just a gimmick, it’s a game-changer.

No hoagie is complete without the perfect beer, and Hoagies and Hops has you covered with a selection from Indianapolis' Chilly Water Brewing. Among the core lineup you’ll find the Built to Last Pilsner, Blood on the Tracks blood orange IPA, and One Hop Wonder IPA. For a crisp, refreshing choice, the Built to Last Pilsner is a standout. Crafted with German-grown barley and a blend of Hallertau and Czech Saaz hops, it offers a smooth, subtly spicy flavor with a clean, balanced finish - perfect for pairing with any hoagie on the menu.

Let’s be real, though. What truly makes Hoagies and Hops shine isn’t just the sandwiches but the people behind them. The staff here isn’t just handing you food, they’re delivering a taste of Pennsylvania with a side of hometown hospitality. Whether you’re talking about the best beer to pair with your hoagie or getting schooled on the art of the perfect hoagie roll, they’re genuinely excited to share their love for the craft. You’ll feel like you’ve found your new favorite spot in no time.

After you’ve devoured your hoagie and savored a cold one, there’s plenty more to explore in Indianapolis. You can dive into culture at the Indianapolis Museum of Art, enjoy a show at the Indiana Repertory Theatre, or take a relaxing bike ride along the Canal Walk.

If you’re staying the night, Indy has no shortage of vacation rentals where you can rest up and fuel up for more adventures. We love this one. It's close to everything and boasts an outdoor hot tub and an indoor fireplace - the best of both worlds!

So pack your bags, bring your appetite, and head to Hoagies and Hops - because no trip to Indy is complete without one of its legendary hoagies; and after you try one, you’ll see why this place is quickly becoming a local favorite.