Posted in Florida American, Bakeries & Dessert, Food & Dining, Hidden Gems, Iconic Foods February 14, 2023 by Marisa Roman

People Are Going Crazy Over The Handmade Pies At This Charming Florida Pie Shop

Visiting Atlantic Beach in Florida, you might come across a tiny, charming bakery and cafe known as Pie Heaven. And even if you don’t stumble upon it by happenstance, we suggest making a beeline to see what you’ve been missing. Pie Heaven is a charming pie shop in Atlantic Beach, Florida that people go crazy for. Picture fresh, handmade pies of all different varieties, waiting to be sliced into and indulged.

If you want more Florida restaurants, make sure to click here and sign up for our weekly dining newsletter. Every Thursday, a new eatery to try in the Sunshine State will be delivered straight to your email. Yum!

Pie Heaven in Atlantic Beach, Florida, is a popular bakery and cafe serving delicious handmade pies.

Helmed by owner and master pie baker Anita Hyde, people come from all over to taste the savory, sweet, custardy variety of pies here.

Using only pie ingredients, which means no hydrogenated oils, high fructose corn syrup, preservatives, and artificial sweeteners, these pies are made with the utmost care and craft.

Stepping into this small-but-mighty pie shop, you’ll likely smell something cooking almost immediately.

The range of pies offered here is truly something to marvel over. If you want to start with something savory, try the famous chicken pot pie, quiche, or spaghetti pie!

Try the fluffy top pies, like banana cream, coconut cream, and chocolate cream…

…the pecan pies are also fan-favorites, like the classic pecan, bourbon pecan, or chocolate bourbon pecan. Also, the fruit pies are sweet and spectacular.

Also, baked custard pies are in the house, too. Coconut custard, classic Key lime, take your pick! Pies rotate, too, on a seasonal basis, so you can almost always find something new when you visit.

No matter what you choose to indulge in, Pie Heaven will surely satisfy you.

Have you ever visited Pie Heaven in Florida? What were your thoughts about this pie shop in Atlantic Beach, Florida? Share with us in the comments section! Or, if you want to know more about this pie shop, including current hours of operation, then check out the Pie Heaven website or Pie Heaven Facebook Page.

If you want to spend the entire day in the Atlantic Beach area, then start with a trip to Dano’s Diner! This incredible burger shop in Florida has been around since the 1980s.

OnlyInYourState may earn compensation through affiliate links in this article.

Address: Pie Heaven Bakery Cafe, 1980 Mayport Rd, Atlantic Beach, FL 32233, USA

People Are Going Crazy Over The Handmade Pies At This Charming Florida Pie Shop

Open For Nearly Half A Century, Dining At Mel’s Hot Dogs In Florida Is Always A Timeless Experience

It Should Be Illegal To Drive Through Madeira Beach Without Stopping At The Candy Kitchen

This Delicious Restaurant In Florida On A Rural Country Road Is A Hidden Culinary Gem

This Candy Store In Florida Was Ripped Straight From The Pages Of A Fairytale

The Remote Restaurant That Serves The Best Fried Chicken In Florida

The Unique Restaurant In Florida Where Every Order Comes With A Free Bucket Of Peanuts

Visit The Small-Batch Chocolate Shop In Florida, Where Everything Is Made By Hand

Some Of The Most Mouthwatering BBQ In Florida Is Served At This Unassuming Local Gem

People Are Going Crazy Over The Handmade Pies At This Charming Florida Pie Shop

Florida In Your Inbox