Posted in Wyoming Bakeries & Dessert, Food & Dining December 19, 2022 by Megan Todaro

It’s Worth It To Drive Across Wyoming Just For The Homemade Pies At Cowboy Cafe

Have a sweet tooth that needs satisfying? You’ve come to the right place. We have a cafe in the tiny, Western-themed town of Dubois that will become your go-to place for delicious, delectable homemade pies. See why many have said these are the best homemade pies in Wyoming – bar none.

There’s a cafe in the heart of the small, Western town of Dubois, Wyoming, that rivals them all in classic American cuisine.

Cowboy Cafe is a beloved local staple in this small town, serving up traditional American fare, western-style.

And while you can get thick-cut steaks, classic burgers, and plates of barbecue-coated ribs, it’s the desserts at this spot that reign supreme.

Feeding both locals and tourists some homemade sweets, the pies are always a’plenty when you visit Cowboy Cafe.

Many visitors to this cafe have declared this to be the best pie in Wyoming, worth a drive from across the state to chow down.

Inside might be tiny, but you’ll find a list of pies on the board once you walk in, ranging from traditional apple, peach, and pecan…

…to specialty pies like apple caramel crunch, strawberry rhubarb, toffee pecan, and chocolate mousse.

You can have a slice of fresh pie to cap off any meal…

…or order online and take an entire pie to go!

The good news is for pie lovers, you have not one but TWO Cowboy Cafe locations to choose from - Dubois and Sheridan. We’re just partial to the more Western-inclined Dubois location to give us a hometown experience.

Have you ever had pie from Cowboy Cafe? Do you think these are the best pies in Wyoming? Tell us about it in the comments! Or to find out the new pie flavors each day, visit the Cowboy Cafe website or Facebook Page.

After you’re done feasting on pies, walk around town a bit! Dubois, Wyoming, is considered one of the best-kept secrets of the state.

Address: Cowboy Cafe, 115 E Rams Horn, Dubois, WY 82513, USA

Address: Cowboy Cafe, 138 N Main St, Sheridan, WY 82801, USA

OnlyInYourState may earn compensation through affiliate links in this article.