Sister Bay Bowl: The Best Supper Club And Bowling Alley In Wisconsin

If someone asked us to create the most perfectly Wisconsin spot, we’re not sure we could have created anything better than Sister Bay Bowl. This gorgeous old building used to house a hotel, but today it’s a one-stop shop for killer cocktails, an amazing fish fry and of course a few frames of bowling. That’s right, this supper club and bowling alley in Wisconsin perfectly sums up everything that we love about living in this great state. You’ll find yourself returning to this special destination again and again.

This historic building was once the Sister Bay Hotel. But in 1950, the Williams family purchased the Sister Bay Hotel and started welcoming visitors. In 1958, Earl and Rita tore down the dance hall (a Saturday night hot spot for locals) and built a six-lane bowling alley. In 1964, they opened the supper club. Now, the third generation of this family is serving up one of the most awesome and amazing combination spots in Wisconsin.

It certainly doesn't get more Wisconsin than a supper club, corner bar and bowling alley all combined into one. Come for the Fish Fry and then stay to bowl a few games. Every kids' meal even comes with a free game of bowling!

In the summer months, plan to end your night outside enjoying their gorgeous outdoor bar and patio that often features live music. If you've never thought of a one-stop shop that covers all your evening's entertainment and dining needs, you're going to be in for a surprise at Sister Bay Bowl.

The tagline here is "Come for the food, stay for the fun" and it's pretty fitting. There's nowhere else in the state quite like this place. It should be a Wisconsin institution as it combines all kinds of state standards. The food is delicious and well-priced, though there is often a wait to get a table.

That's ok, though, as there's the kind of bar that makes you want to sit down and stay awhile as you sip on a perfect Old Fashioned. It's warm and cozy and welcoming and chock full of friendly people. Despite being both a bowling alley bar and the supper club's bar, it's also a wonderful little neighborhood spot where friends meet and relax.

Even if bowling isn't on your menu for the night, you'll still want to head to Sister Bay Bowl for some of the best supper club food in the area. These folks aren't taking any short cuts. They've been doing this for 60 years and there's still a line on the weekends, so you know they're doing things right. This isn't just a novelty, this is a Door County institution serving up broasted chicken, fish fry, prime rib, surf and turf and more to the lucky locals who visit each night.

Settle in with a cocktail, dig deep in your brain to remember how to manually score a bowling game and settle in for some old-school Wisconsin fun. These lanes used to be the hotel dance hall, so you know the walls have more stories than we can imagine. There's history here and you're going to want to add your name to the pages.

Sister Bay Bowl is a delightful, unique and totally amazing spot that we are so lucky to have right here in Wisconsin. It combines all the great things about our state, from patio drinks to prime rib, old fashioneds to old school bowling. This little gem is the perfect place to waste away a Door County night on your next trip.

Have you ever been to this truly spectacular supper club and bowling alley in Wisconsin? If so, we want to hear all about it! Share your thoughts with us in the comments below. And if you know another fun place to eat in Wisconsin, nominate it for a chance to be featured.

Did you know that Wisconsin is home to the USA’s oldest sanctioned bowling alley? If you’ve never been, you absolutely have to spend some time at Holler House.

OnlyInYourState may earn compensation through affiliate links in this article. As an Amazon Associate, we earn from qualifying purchases.

More to Explore

supper club and bowling alley in Wisconsin

Elisa Regulski | July 06, 2020

What are the most fun places to eat in Wisconsin?

There are so many fun places to eat in Wisconsin. For some tasty meals the whole family will love, visit Georgie Porgie's. This vibrant eatery has locations in Oak Creek and Mount Pleasant, so it’s super easy to satisfy your cravings for tasty burgers. This treehouse themed eatery is full of excitement. For more colorful fun, visit Maggie's in Bayfield. You may know this as the flamingo themed bar. It’s hard to pass by this unique destination. Looking for more dining inspiration? Check out our list of the most wacky restaurants in Wisconsin.

What are the best supper clubs in Wisconsin?

Wisconsinites love a good supper club, and we have tons of great places. If you really want to enjoy an evening off the beaten path, check out our list of the best small town supper clubs in Wisconsin. These delicious destinations may not be the most famous restaurants in the state, but they’re every bit as scrumptious as the highly rated joints. So what are you waiting for? Sip on an old fashioned and sink your teeth into a hearty steak dinner. You’re going to love these extraordinary businesses.

What are the best bowling alleys in Wisconsin?

Looking for an afternoon of fun? There are tons of exciting bowling alleys in Wisconsin. If you really want to soak up some history, visit Falcon Bowl in Milwaukee. This place isn’t just a great place to spend an evening -- it’s the oldest bowling alley in the nation! You must add this to the top of your Wisconsin bucket list. If you loved this place, you should also visit Algoma Pizza Bowl. This place is known for their tasty pizza and exciting atmosphere.

Featured Addresses

Sister Bay Bowl, 10640 N Bay Shore Dr, Sister Bay, WI 54234, USA

A Wisconsin Supper Club And Bowling Alley, Sister Bay Bowl Is Loads Of Fun

Nicole

Author

Related Stories

With Its Own Private Playground, This Incredible Cafe In Wisconsin Is Perfect For Families

This Speakeasy Hidden In An Old Harness Shop In Wisconsin Is Perfect For A Date Night

I Toured A Cheese Museum In Wisconsin Because Of Course I Did

Want more Wisconsin in your inbox?

More to Explore

supper club and bowling alley in Wisconsin

Related Articles

Featured Addresses