There are lots of bakeries in Wisconsin. But if it’s authentic Italian sweets you’re craving, Peter Sciortino Bakery is the place for you. The Milwaukee staple has been around for decades, and we’re guessing the authentic Italian sweets just might have something to do with that. Take a look:

This is Peter Sciortino Bakery. The Brady Street institution opened in 1947 and has been a local favorite for nearly as long.
John Smith/Google
The popular bakeshop has been voted "Milwaukee’s Best Bakery." However, many patrons would argue that it's "Wisconsin’s Best Bakery."
Peter Sciortino Bakery/Facebook
And after one visit, you’ll quickly see what all the fuss is about. The aroma of fresh-baked bread, rolls, and cookies is sure to be the first thing you notice when you set foot inside the bakery.
Peter Sciortino Bakery/Facebook
A stocked display case will likely be the second.
Barbra A/TripAdvisor
Take a look inside and you’ll find a delectable selection of authentic Italian cookies and pastries – all of which is made from scratch daily.
Peter Sciortino Bakery/Facebook

Related Stories

Stop By Kelley Country Creamery, A Charming Ice Cream Shop With Delicious Hard Scoop In Wisconsin

Stop By Kelley Country Creamery, A Charming Ice Cream Shop With Delicious Hard Scoop In Wisconsin

 Housed In An Old Schoolhouse, A Visit To Uncle Tom's Candy Shop In Wisconsin Is A Unique Treat

Housed In An Old Schoolhouse, A Visit To Uncle Tom's Candy Shop In Wisconsin Is A Unique Treat

 One Of The Nation's Best Restaurants, Stockholm Pie And General Store In Wisconsin, Lives Up To Its Reputation

One Of The Nation's Best Restaurants, Stockholm Pie And General Store In Wisconsin, Lives Up To Its Reputation
A customer favorite, the cookies have been a bakery specialty since the beginning. In addition to taste, it’s the variety that’s impressive.
Peter Sciortino Bakery/Facebook
The sweet selection includes all the classics, like Anise toast, cimino, and biscotti.
Peter Sciortino Bakery/Facebook
The authentic treats don’t end with the cookies, though. There are also Italian pastries.
Pat Lehnherr/Google
Tiramisu, sfogliatelle, and cannoli are just a few of the classic pastries offered. And just like the cookies, the pastries taste like they came straight from Italy.
MH T/Google
Aside from Italian sweets, the bakery sells fresh baked Italian breads and rolls, which are as much a customer favorite as the desserts.
Peter Sciortino Bakery/Facebook
Between the amount of time it's been in business to the consistent rave reviews, Peter Sciortino Bakery is surely doing something right - and it's pretty sweet.
Melanie Worley/Google

Can’t make it to Peter Sciortino Bakery? Don’t worry; the bakery ships their baked goods all over the country, so you can enjoy their tasty baked goods, no matter where you are. For more information, call (414) 272-4623. You can also visit the bakery’s website or Facebook page.

Address: 1101 E Brady Street, Milwaukee, WI, 53202

This isn’t the state’s only bakery with authentic eats. Read about another here.

OnlyInYourState may earn compensation through affiliate links in this article. As an Amazon Associate, we earn from qualifying purchases.

Related Articles

Explore Wisconsin