Nothing beats homemade pie. If you agree, then there’s one place in the Buckeye State that demands your attention. Home to some of the best pie in Ohio, Mehaffies Pies is famous for its made-from-scratch recipes. In fact, at any given time, you’ll find an impressive variety of more than 30 flavors to choose from. Now that’s a lot of pie. Here’s more on why a trip to Mehaffies Pies belongs on every dessert enthusiast’s radar.

Despite its rather unassuming exterior, Mehaffies is home to what some consider to be the best pie in Ohio. Step inside, and you'll find yourself surrounded by the irresistible scent of freshly-baked goods.
Shawn Moorman / Google
No matter the time of year you visit, you can look forward to dozens upon dozens of varieties. In fact, you may have trouble deciding on just one!
Dustin Johnson / Google
Fortunately, you'll find that the display case gives you a good idea of what's in store. This may help you narrow down your options.
Regina Whitenack / Google

Related Stories

With Flavors That Sell Out Daily, Partial To Pie Is The Tastiest, Most Creative Bakery In Ohio

With Flavors That Sell Out Daily, Partial To Pie Is The Tastiest, Most Creative Bakery In Ohio

 Sink Your Teeth Into Authentic Hungarian Pastries At Lydia's Strudel Shop In Ohio

Sink Your Teeth Into Authentic Hungarian Pastries At Lydia's Strudel Shop In Ohio

 Ohio's Incredible Milkshake Bar Is What Dreams Are Made Of

Ohio's Incredible Milkshake Bar Is What Dreams Are Made Of
And while every pie is worth sampling, strawberry seems to be one of the most popular. Just look at all of that delicious fruit!
kristi higa / Google
As you can imagine, Mehaffies is especially popular around the holidays, when flavors such as apple, pecan, and pumpkin are in high demand.
Kathleen Millhouse / Google
In addition to pie, you'll find some other delicious sweets to try, including cheesecakes, pumpkin rolls, brownies, and much more.
Daniel Green / Google

Have you ever sampled a pie from Mehaffies Pies? Do you agree that this spot serves up the best pie in Ohio? Be sure to share your thoughts with us in the comments below — we’d love to hear from you! For more information, you can check out Mehaffies Pies online. You can also call (937) 253-1163 for more information.

OnlyInYourState may earn compensation through affiliate links in this article. As an Amazon Associate, we earn from qualifying purchases.

Related Articles

Explore Ohio

Featured Addresses
Mehaffies Pies, 3013 Linden Ave, Dayton, OH 45410, USA