Nothing beats a small town bakery… except maybe a small town bakery that’s home to the world’s largest pumpkin pie. Lindsey’s Bakery in Circleville, Ohio features some of the state’s best donuts, cookies, cakes and pies. Family owned and operated for more than 60 years, it’s a true Ohio treasure. The baked goods here are legendary; in fact, we do declare Lindsey’s to make the best pumpkin pie in Ohio! And all it takes is one visit to see why.

Tucked away in the small town of Circleville, you'll find one of the best bakeshops in all of Ohio.
Lindsey's Bakery/Google
It's a best kept secret for locals and a pleasant surprise for visitors.
Since 1950, the Lindsey family has been serving up always fresh, never frozen baked goods. Everything here is delicious.
Lindsey's Bakery/Facebook
With a wide variety of baked goods, (all of which are completely made from scratch,) it can be difficult to choose.
You can't leave Lindsey's Bakery without some pumpkin donuts, which are (thankfully) made year-round...
Lindsey's Bakery/Facebook
...but be aware that if you come for pumpkin donuts during the Circleville Pumpkin Show, you will wait in a long, out-the-door line that weaves through the sidewalk. (It's totally worth it though!)

Related Stories

You Must Try The Buckeye Pie At This Unique Homestyle Restaurant In Ohio

You Must Try The Buckeye Pie At This Unique Homestyle Restaurant In Ohio

 It's Worth It To Drive Across Ohio Just For The Butterscotch Donuts At Destination Donuts

It's Worth It To Drive Across Ohio Just For The Butterscotch Donuts At Destination Donuts

 Barcelona Just Might Have The Most Epic Dessert Selection In All Of Ohio

Barcelona Just Might Have The Most Epic Dessert Selection In All Of Ohio
During the Circleville Pumpkin Show season in October, the bakery also prepares and displays a massive pumpkin pie. In fact, it's the world's largest.
Lindsey's Bakery/Facebook
Lindsey's Bakery has held the record for the world's largest pumpkin pie for more than 40 years. In 2005, the bakery made a pie that measured a whopping 18 feet across, taking back the world record yet again.
For decades, thousands of families have flocked to Lindsey's Bakery during the town's festival to see the massive pie and purchase some pumpkin donuts.
Lindsey's Bakery/Facebook
More than 400,00 people flock to the small town of Circleville each year to attend the Pumpkin Show, one of the biggest and best fall festivals in the Buckeye State!
Another delicious, simple treat the bakery makes year-round are thumbprint cookies, which you can get in a variety of colors.
Lindsey's Bakery/Facebook
They're perfect for any holiday, game day or any other special occasion you might be celebrating.

Have you ever been to Lindsey’s Bakery before? If so, did you get some pumpkin donuts? Do you agree that this bakeshop makes the best pumpkin pie in Ohio? Share your thoughts and experiences with us!

For more delicious bakery destinations, check out our previous article: There’s A Bakery On This Beautiful Farm In Ohio And You Have To Visit.

OnlyInYourState may earn compensation through affiliate links in this article. As an Amazon Associate, we earn from qualifying purchases.

More to Explore

Best pumpkin pie in Ohio

Sarah M. | August 20, 2022

What are the best pumpkin patches in Ohio?

If learning about where you could get the best pumpkin pie in Ohio ignited your craving for all things pumpkin, you'll want to check out these amazing pumpkin patches in the Buckeye State! We adore small-town favorites like Fulton Farms, Honey Haven Farm, Lincoln Ridge Farms, Shaw Farms, and Harvest Adventures. In terms of amazing pumpkin patches in Ohio that also boast some of the best fall festivals in the state, nothing beats Blooms and Berries in Loveland, Ohio. Their annual Fall on the Farm festival is the stuff of fall festival dreams! From epic corn mazes (they have two: a shorter maze for kids, and a longer maze for corn maze enthusiasts), hay rides, cow trains, farm animals, an epic pumpkin-shaped bounce pad, sunflower fields, pumpkin patches aplenty, a beer garden, and tons of fresh-baked goodies (including apple cider and apple cider donuts), there's no fall festival (or pumpkin patch) in Ohio quite like Fall on the Farm at Blooms and Berries!

Related Articles

Explore Ohio

Featured Addresses
Lindsey's Bakery, 127 W Main St, Circleville, OH 43113, USA