When was the last time you enjoyed a peanut butter and jam sandwich? It might be the food of your childhood, but the peanut butter at this little nut shop in Columbus is gourmet fare that’s a far cry from the stuff you ate as a kid. You definitely need to put Krema Nut Company on your list. In fact, you’d be nuts not to visit this peanut butter shop in Ohio.

Krema Nut Company has been in business since 1898, and if you've never visited, you definitely need to check this place out.
Eric K/Google
Address: 1000 Goodale Boulevard, Columbus, OH, 43212
This little shop offers a large selection of roasted nuts. The nuts are roasted in small batches by a master roaster who has been with the company for more than 25 years, and you can definitely taste the difference in the quality.
craig clark/Google
The roasted nuts are amazing, but just wait til you taste the nut butters that are made with them! Krema Nut Company is one of the oldest peanut butter manufacturers in the country, and they fill every jar by hand.
Krema Nut Company/Facebook
Pick up a jar of peanut, almond, or cashew butter, then head to the store's kitchen to get a delicious sandwich.
Banana B/Zomato
You'll find a dozen different sandwiches on the menu, and these are nothing like the PB&J of your childhood.
Krema Nut Company

Related Stories

Escape To The Countryside When You Stay At This Rural Airbnb In Ohio

Escape To The Countryside When You Stay At This Rural Airbnb In Ohio

 This Speakeasy Hidden In The Walk-In Cooler Of A Pizza Parlor In Ohio Is Perfect For A Date Night

This Speakeasy Hidden In The Walk-In Cooler Of A Pizza Parlor In Ohio Is Perfect For A Date Night

 Best Waterfalls in Ohio: 14 Local Favorites & Hidden Gems

Best Waterfalls in Ohio: 14 Local Favorites & Hidden Gems
Each gourmet sandwich is offered on white or whole wheat bread, and includes Krema Nut Company's fresh peanut, almond, or cashew butters. This is the classic Krema Special, made with peanut butter and strawberry preserves or grape jelly.
Krema Nut Company/Facebook
Some say the Krema Special is one of the best sandwiches in Ohio.
You might also like the PB Nana. The bread is toasted, and the peanut butter is accompanied by honey and fresh, sliced bananas.
Krema Nut Company/Facebook
Other sandwiches are more quirky. The Grandma's Apple Pie sandwich includes ground peanut butter and apple pie filling.
Siera Hayes/Google
Other sandwiches include the Nutty Mallow with marshmallow fluff, the Buckeye with peanut butter and Nutella, the Classic Old Timer with strawberry preserves and fresh sliced strawberries, and more.
For dessert, try one of Krema's famous milkshakes, an ice cream sundae, or a cookie and peanut butter ice cream sandwich.
Katie Ferrin/Zomato
There are so many reasons to love this specialty food store in Ohio.
Visit Krema Nut Company Monday through Friday from 9 a.m. to 5 p.m. and Saturday from 10 a.m. to 2 p.m. The kitchen is open Monday through Friday from 10 a.m. to 4:30 p.m. and Saturday from 10 a.m. to 1:30 p.m.
Laura McCoy/Google
Please Note: Krema Nut Company is closed on Sundays. Learn more about Krema Nut Company on its website, and make sure to follow its Facebook page to see what's new there.

Have you visited this peanut butter shop in Ohio? What’s your favorite thing on the menu? Share your thoughts with us in the comments below!

If you’re looking for dining that’s a bit more grown up, check out this wine bar in Marblehead.

OnlyInYourState may earn compensation through affiliate links in this article. As an Amazon Associate, we earn from qualifying purchases.

More to Explore

peanut butter shop in ohio

Elisa Regulski | February 10, 2020

What are the best specialty food stores in Ohio?

European Specialty Food Mart is one of the most unique shops in Ohio. They have a wide selection of baked goods and beer, but you really haven’t lived until you’ve tried their pierogi. This Polish treat is packed with flavor, and no one does it better than this Brunswick business. For more worldly eats, visit LVIV International Food Store in Cleveland. People always rave about this specialty food store in Ohio, and it’s easy to see why. Their deli is packed with scrumptious goods, and their freshly baked bread is mouthwatering.

What are the best places to get peanut butter in Ohio?

For more scrumptious spreads, devour Crazy Richard's Peanut Butter. This beloved company is based in Plain City, Ohio, and they make the Buckeye State proud. Indulge in their creative concoctions and let your taste buds dance for joy.

What are the best sandwich shops in Ohio?

Krema Nut Company’s nutty creations aren’t the only wonderful sandwiches in Ohio. For another magnificent dining experience, visit Slyman’s Restaurant in Cleveland. They are known for their corned beef sandwiches, and people can’t get enough. These sandwiches are massive, so come hungry! Katzinger’s Delicatessen, located in Columbus, is another fantastic place to get sandwiches in Ohio. While you can’t go wrong with any of their 77 sandwiches, they are most famous for their Reuben. This indulgent dish is pure bliss. Really, it’s worth going out of your way for.

Related Articles

Featured Addresses
1000 Goodale Blvd, Columbus, OH 43212, USA