Posted in New York Dining August 09, 2017 by

The Unassuming Restaurant In New York That Serves The Best Pizza You’ll Ever Taste

If you haven’t already figured it out by now, the best tasting restaurants that you’ll ever discover in the Empire State are the ones that don’t look like much from the outside. Embodying the phrase “never judge a books by its cover” the fullest extent, there’s one secluded restaurant that you simply can’t let go undetected from your foodie radar. A dining destination that will have you walking away with a belly full of pizza and the desire to come back for more, keep reading to find out why you absolutely need to visit this place.

During these uncertain times, please keep safety in mind and consider adding destinations to your bucket list to visit at a later date.
Located in the small town of Averill Park, Kay's Pizza will have your mouth watering by the time you're done reading this post.
Roger K./Yelp
Just outside of Albany in an unsuspecting location, one of the only things that would lead a stranger to believe that this spot is worth checking out is the long line of cars you can always find here.
Roger K./Yelp
Open for the season until mid-October, this family-friendly atmosphere is one you'll want to enjoy with loved ones before they close again for the year.
Roger K./Yelp
Kay's features a menu that will accommodate everyone that you bring with you for dinner, but the reason this place draws in so many visitors is because of their phenomenal pizza.
Mark F/TripAdvisor
Cooking up fresh homemade pizza since 1958, Kay's family recipe has been passed down for ages and includes 100% mozzarella cheese that's shredded fresh every day.
Brew M./Yelp
The casual spot is great to visit on any day of the week and is open to quench our hunger daily with freshly made dough and sauce.
LakeRecluse/TripAdvisor
Kay's menu features all of the classic varieties of pizzas that you would expect, plus a few other menu items and toppings that will give your taste buds a shock.
Steve N./Yelp
From standards like the Buffalo Chicken and Bacon pizzas to delicious toppings like Chopped Clams and Crispy Chicken, you'll rightfully have a hard time choosing what pie you want to devour for yourself.
Brew M./Yelp
Right on the shores of Burden Lake, start planning your trip to Kay's now before this fantastic spot shuts its doors for the year.
Kay's Pizza/Facebook
Open Monday through Saturday from 4PM to 10PM and Sundays from 3PM to 9PM, you'll be able to feast on one of the most memorable pizza dinners you'll ever have in New York State. Kay's operates on a first-come, first serve basis where you can seat yourself - so the earlier you arrive the better!
To view the tasty menu and to find out more information, click here.

How to get here: 10 Walsh Lane Averill Park, NY 12018

What’s your favorite thing to order when you visit Kay’s? If you’re looking for another small town eatery to check out, find out why Everyone Goes Nuts For The Hamburgers At This Nostalgic Eatery In New York!