These 8 Amazing New York Restaurants Are Loaded With Local History
It’s no secret that New York is home to a vast amount of fascinating historical locations. But if you’re looking to soak in local history inside of a charming environment, all while managing to keep your belly full? Then you’ll want to add these nine amazing restaurants in the Empire State to your 2017 dining bucket list!



If It wasn't for the signage out on the front lawn, anyone could easily drive by this house assuming that it was just another one of New York's charming small town homes. But upon further inspection, you'll discover that the town of Potsdam is home to this hidden treasure, a historic restaurant that once was a farmhand's house back in 1844. A location with quite the long history, it wasn't until 1985 that the lovely home would be converted into a restaurant. An interior made up of nostalgic decor and gorgeous wood fixtures, the 1844 House is now known for pumping out incredible American Bistro style dishes.
To find out more information about the 1844 House in Potsdam, click here.
How to get here: 6885 SR 11 Potsdam, NY 13676
To find out more information about the 1844 House in Potsdam, click here.
How to get here: 6885 SR 11 Potsdam, NY 13676



Right in one of our favorite foodie cities to visit within in New York, Utica is home to The Tailor and the Cook. The building itself has a long history, with the owners paying homage to a previous business by choosing to name their restaurant after the UTK Tailoring Company that occupied the building from 1910 until the 1940s. How neat! Did you know the story behind this restaurant's name? The restaurant's food has earned quite the reputation, serving farm-to-table dishes that leave visitors in awe.
To find out more information about this incredible dining location, click here.
How to get here: 94 Genesee Street Utica, NY 13502
To find out more information about this incredible dining location, click here.
How to get here: 94 Genesee Street Utica, NY 13502



A common theme you'll see amongst many of the restaurant interiors? That their structures are made up of beautiful wood and nostalgic decor that will throw you back in time as soon as you step foot through the door. With that said, this couldn't be more true for Ulrich's Tavern. Just one of the many extraordinary places you can dine at in this city, Ulrich's has undergone extensive renovations in recent years but still has managed to stand still in time. More than just a bar, this tavern features a menu that will have your mouth watering.
To find out more information about this location, click here.
How to get here: 674 Ellicott Street Buffalo, NY 14203
To find out more information about this location, click here.
How to get here: 674 Ellicott Street Buffalo, NY 14203


Right along the southern shores of Cazenovia Lake, not far from other scenic and historic locations in town, is The Brewster Inn. Built back in 1890, the restaurant was originally the home of financier Benjamin B. Brewster. Made up of mahogany and oak, the restaurant has an unforgettable atmosphere that will blow you away.
To view the inn's tasty menus and to find out more information, click here.
How to get here: 6 Ledyard Avenue Cazenovia, NY 13035
To view the inn's tasty menus and to find out more information, click here.
How to get here: 6 Ledyard Avenue Cazenovia, NY 13035


Built back in 1847, the American Hotel of Sharon Springs is a building that will grab your attention. The historic exterior looks far from modern, welcoming guests since it reopened its doors in 2001. After remaining vacant for over 30 years, the property was purchased and was revamped after a five-year long renovation. Ever since the hotel opened back up for business it has been a popular destination for visitors to check out in the area, now featuring a fantastic dining room.
To find out more information about this historical hotel and to view their menus, click here.
How to get here: 155 Main Street Sharon Springs, NY 13459
To find out more information about this historical hotel and to view their menus, click here.
How to get here: 155 Main Street Sharon Springs, NY 13459



Operating on the Adirondack Coast since 1812, the Essex Inn is waiting for you on the shores of Lake Champlain. With the inn being nearly as old as the town of Essex itself, it's needless to say that this cozy location is filled with fascinating history. Once the busiest seaport on the lake, the town and restaurant was long a popular location for merchants, locals and travelers. After undergoing renovations, the inn is now the perfect place for visitors to enjoy modern day amenities while surrounding yourself in a rustic, historic setting.
To find out more information about how you can enjoy this undeniably amazing location, click here.
How to get here: 2297 Main Street Essex, NY 12936
To find out more information about how you can enjoy this undeniably amazing location, click here.
How to get here: 2297 Main Street Essex, NY 12936



The town of Skaneateles is home to a handful of charming locations that you'll want to check out while you're in the area, but if there's only room for one place to add on to your bucket list you'll want to choose The Krebs! Founded in 1899, the restaurant has been an iconic location of the area for more than a hundred years.
To find out more information about The Krebs, click here.
How to get here: 53 West Genesee Street Skaneateles, NY 13152
To find out more information about The Krebs, click here.
How to get here: 53 West Genesee Street Skaneateles, NY 13152


Another gem of the Adirondacks, the Merrill Magee Inn of Warrensburg is just one of the many historic locations you can find hiding up north in New York. Listed on the National Register of Historic Places, the inn features an amazing farm to table restaurant right in the heart of town. Apart of Warrensburg's history since 1839, the location remained a private residence until 1981 when it was converted into a tradition inn.
To read more about the inn's history and to check out their wonderful menus, click here.
How to get here: 3 Hudson Street Warrensburg, NY 12885
To read more about the inn's history and to check out their wonderful menus, click here.
How to get here: 3 Hudson Street Warrensburg, NY 12885
Still feeling hungry? Then quench your hunger by planning a trip to one of these 11 BBQ Joints In New York That Will Leave Your Mouth Watering Uncontrollably!
OnlyInYourState may earn compensation through affiliate links in this article.