We’re back to take you on another great adventure! Recently we mapped out a delicious Ice Cream Trail that takes you through some of the most beautiful parts of the Adirondacks. Usually, when it comes to planning out an adventure for our readers, we focus on one region of our state to make things realistic. If we were to plan out an ultimate ice cream trail featuring the best ice cream in New York, it would likely end up taking days to complete. And while it would be nice to imagine spending an entire week traveling all around the Empire State dining on nothing but unforgettable desserts, not many of us actually have the time to do that.

With that said, another region of our state is up to bat! Today you’ll now find a mapped out excursion that will bring you to some of the tastiest locations around the Finger Lakes. With ten ice cream shops that are all unique and equipped with what it takes to win your heart (and stomach) over, this ice cream trail is what dreams are made of. Your next adventure starts here…

To view the entire trip on Google Maps, click here.
Google Maps
1. Pittsford Farms Dairy - Monroe County
FLNomad/TripAdvisor
Larry W/TripAdvisor
While most of the destinations that are part of this road trip are out among our Finger Lakes, Pittsford Farms is one of the few that strays from the region. Right outside of Rochester in the charming town of Pittsford is a location that's known for out-of-this-world dairy items. From unforgettable milk to endless ice cream flavors that are available all year long, this is the perfect place to start your ice cream adventure.

To find out more information about this amazing farm, click here.
Address: 44 N Main St, Pittsford, NY 14534
2. Scoops - Canandaigua
Larry W/TripAdvisor
Larry W/TripAdvisor
Taking you to the northern shores of Canandaigua Lake, Scoops is a wonderful location if you're looking to be near the water. Right out front you'll find quirky decor, having you sitting in ice cream cones while you enjoy your own soft-serve delights.

To find out more information about this whimsical spot, click here.
Address: 10 Lakeshore Dr, Canandaigua, NY 14424
3. Mr. Twistee's - Dresden
William L./Yelp
Mr. Twistee's/Facebook
Next stop, Dresden! Taking you out towards the western shores of Seneca Lake, Mr. Twistee's actually has another location in Geneva that you can also visit. A long time local favorite, this ice cream shop features all of your favorite classics alongside new menu items like Waffle Nachos!

To find out more information about this unique destination, click here.
Address: Dresden, NY 14527
4. Seneca Farms - Penn Yan
beagle09/TripAdvisor
OliviaAugust/TripAdvisor
Head out to the eastern branch of Keuka Lake and you'll find plenty to keep yourself busy in the small town of Penn Yan. Residents from the area will sing nothing but high praises about this location, serving up American style food that will leave you feeling nothing less than full.

To find out more information about this family favorite shop, click here.
Address: 2485 NY-54A, Penn Yan, NY 14527
5. Colonial Inn - Watkins Glen
2cindym/TripAdvisor
Joe M./Yelp
You may be familiar with the town of Watkins Glen because of its home to one of the dreamiest state parks you'll ever explore, but it's also features an amazing place to stay that you'll want to check out. The Colonial Inn makes drool-inducing homemade ice cream that you'll love to enjoy in this scenic town.

To find out more information on this amazing place to stay, click here.
Address: 701 N Franklin St #1303, Watkins Glen, NY 14891
6. Dippity Do Dahs - Corning
Myron E./Yelp
Linda L./Yelp
Bringing you down into our Southern Tier, Dippity Do Dahs is just a two-minute drive from the Corning Museum of Glass. A great place to stop after spending a day exploring one of our most extraordinary museums, this ice cream shop has been drawing in locals since 2013. One of our favorite features of Market Street, it's impossible to walk by this fantastic shop without stopping in for some dessert.

To find out more information about this vibrant shop, click here.
Address: 46 E Market St, Corning, NY 14830
7. Jones Humdinger - Binghamton
Scott B./Yelp
Mike K./Yelp
When it comes to discussing the best places to grab ice cream in the city of Binghamton, it's impossible to not bring up Humdinger. Many make the trip out to this area of the Southern Tier to enjoy the city's famous Spiedie's, but if you need a tasty treat to top off your dinner then you'll want to head over to this location.

To find out more information about this wonderful shop, click here.
Address: 1441 Upper, Front St, Binghamton, NY 13901
8. Purity Ice Cream Company - Ithaca
Family_from_NJ/TripAdvisor
Nick H./Yelp
New York's City of Waterfalls is also home to more food destinations than you could possibly have time for one in one day. But if you're going to set aside time to dine for one meal while you're in town, then you should plan on making a dessert trip to Purity Ice Cream. On vintage style shop that will take you back in time, you'll find a variety of desserts here for you to feast on with friends and family.

To find out more information about this old school shop, click here.
Address: 700 Cascadilla St, Ithaca, NY 14850
9. Cayuga Lake Creamery - Interlaken
Cayuga Lake Creamery/Facebook
Nanette M./Yelp
If you're looking for a spot that serves some of the best homemade ice cream you've ever tasted, then you'll need to make sure that you don't miss out on visiting Cayuga Lake Creamery. Out near the western shores of Cayuga Lake, this seasonal destination is well known for flavors like their Sea Salt Caramel Ice Cream.

To find out more information about this scrumptious spot, click here.
Address: 8421 NY-89, Interlaken, NY 14847
10. Chill & Grill - Palmyra
Scott P/TripAdvisor
Chill & Grill/Facebook
Ending the trip by bringing you back up towards the city of Rochester, this Mom & Pop stop is a great place to grab dinner and dessert before getting back into your car. Named the Chill & Grill for obvious reasons, you can find tasty burgers and ice cream flavors that will make your stomach rumble. Aside from the fact that they make amazing ice cream cakes, they also sell enormous ice cream cookie sandwiches that are straight out of your dreams.

To find out more information about this unforgettable location, click here.
Address: 616 E Main St, Palmyra, NY 14522

How many of these tasty destinations have you already had the pleasure of visiting? To take on another regional adventure that will have your mouth watering, lay your eyes on This Cheese Trail In New York That’s Everything You Ever Dreamed Of!

OnlyInYourState may earn compensation through affiliate links in this article.

More to Explore

Best Ice Cream In New York

Marisa Roman | May 07, 2020

What is the most famous ice cream shop in New York?

There are so many wonderful ice cream shops in New York, it can be hard to choose a favorite. However, it might be easier to surmise what the most popular shop in the state is. Serendipity 3 in New York City is one of the most popular ice cream shops in the state, but also in the country. People travel from all over the world to indulge in gargantuan sundaes brimming with toppings. Also, don’t miss out on their famous frozen hot chocolate, which is as decadent as you can imagine.

Where can I find the best desserts in New York?

Spot Dessert Bar in New York is an East Village staple, which allows for sugar-craving tourists to pop in for an epically delightful experience. Really, where else can you find an entire bar dedicated to just desserts?! This cozy little shop is Asian-inspired so prepared yourself for some mocha green tea cupcakes and white-miso semifreddo.

Can I visit any drive-thru ice cream parlors in New York?

There is nothing like scoring some sweet treats without even having to leave your car. One perfect example is Curry Freeze in Rotterdam. This shop has been serving shakes and sundaes to the community for over 50 years. You can place your orders, call for service, and then have your frozen treats delivered straight to your car. How cool is that?! Another option for takeout ice cream in New York is Cappie’s Drive-In in Amsterdam. This drive-up ice cream shop has been open since 1965 and still as tasty as ever.

Related Articles

Explore New York

Featured Addresses
Pittsford Farms Dairy, 44 N Main St, Pittsford, NY 14534, USA
1880 Rochester Rd, Canandaigua, NY 14424, USA
Dresden, NY 14527, USA
2485 NY-54A, Penn Yan, NY 14527, USA
701 N Franklin St #1303, Watkins Glen, NY 14891, USA
46 E Market St, Corning, NY 14830, USA
1441 Upper, Front St, Binghamton, NY 13901, USA
700 Cascadilla St, Ithaca, NY 14850, USA
8421 NY-89, Interlaken, NY 14847, USA
616 E Main St, Palmyra, NY 14522, USA