New York has no shortage of great seafood and fish-and-chips joints, but if you want something completely different, you’ve got to head uptown. LoLo’s Seafood Shack is on 116th street, near the lower boundary of Harlem, and this Caribbean hole-in-the-wall is a memorable experience. From the punchy flavors and unique combos to the charming seating arrangements, this local joint will ensure you never think about fried seafood the same way again.

The colorful outside of LoLo's Seafood Shack lets you know you're on island time as soon as you approach.
Management/TripAdvisor
Inside, the small restaurant only has a few indoor seats, but the atmosphere is effective at transporting you to the Caribbean right away.
Management/TripAdvisor
The Caribbean-themed menu is one of the most authentic in the city, bringing the flavors of the ocean to upper Manhattan.
Management/TripAdvisor
You'll want to start your meal with LoLo's famous Johnny Cakes, slicked with the restaurant's homemade honey butter.
Management/TripAdvisor
The coconut shrimp are plump and fresh with just the right amount of sweetness.
TravelingMomma73/TripAdvisor
But if there's one appetizer that defines the restaurant, it's their flavorful conch fritters.
Management/TripAdvisor
If you still have room, dig into a plate of the restaurant's crispy-fried whitefish and chips.
Lolo's Seafood Shack
Speaking of chips, make sure you add on a side of the addictive plantain chips. Potato who?
Management/TripAdvisor
The most dramatic entree is definitely the crab and shrimp boils, which come in the plastic bag used to toss them in a flavorful sauce.
Raymond M/TripAdvisor
If you're in the mood for something lighter, you won't go wrong with the fresh and spicy Jerk Salmon.
Management/TripAdvisor
If you're here in the summer, grab a seat in the outside backyard cabana and take in the island atmosphere without ever leaving New York!
Management/TripAdvisor

Have you been to LoLo’s Seafood Shack before? Let us know what your favorite items on the island-themed menu are, or if there are any other crispy-fried seafood joints that you think rival it. If you’re planning a visit uptown, make sure to visit the restaurant’s website and Facebook page to learn all about their menu and latest specials.

OnlyInYourState may earn compensation through affiliate links in this article.

Related Articles

Explore New York

Featured Addresses
LoLo's Seafood Shack, 303 W 116th St, New York, NY 10026, USA