Locals Can't Get Enough Of The Homemade, Seasonal Desserts At Erie Coffeeshop & Bakery In New Jersey
By Raymond Goldfield|Published November 14, 2022
Raymond Goldfield is a life-long New Jersey resident and an avid traveler and foodie who can be usually found on the Jersey Shore during the offseason or checking out the latest seasonal flavors at The Bent Spoon in Princeton. He has been working for Only In Your State for since early 2022, where he writes for New Jersey and Iowa and edits the Mid-Atlantic region. He can also be found writing about pop culture for GeekDad. When at home, he enjoys reading comic books and is part of The Rabbitt Stew podcast team. While New Jersey is his home base, he travels regularly and has visited Virginia, Florida, Maine, Minnesota, and Canada as well as all of NJ's border states. Ultimate travel goal? Visit all the best buffets in the United States.
From the exterior, Erie Coffeehouse & Bakery in Rutherford might look like just another small-town coffeeshop. But for those lucky people who open the cafe door, they’re likely to be greeted with the aroma of fresh-baked goodness. This small-batch, family-owned bakery features a constantly rotating array of sweet and savory baked goods to go with your coffee – including what might just be the best pie in New Jersey. What’s the secret of this charming hole-in-the-wall? It’s a combination of inventive flavors, seasonal inspirations, international influences, and a whole lot of passion going into each and every treat. So why not discover exactly what this unique bakery has waiting for you? The odds are the answer will be different every time you visit.
Have you visited Erie Coffeehouse & Bakery in Rutherford? Let us know what you sampled, and tell us your pick for the best pie in New Jersey in the comments section! If you’re interested in sampling for yourself, pay a visit to the cafe’s website and Facebook page to learn all about their current specials. If you’re looking for more of New Jersey’s best pies, why not try this world-famous apple orchard?
OnlyInYourState may earn compensation through affiliate links in this article. As an Amazon Associate, we earn from qualifying purchases.