The Best Pie In New Jersey Is At This Tiny Rutherford Coffee Shop

From the exterior, Erie Coffeehouse & Bakery in Rutherford might look like just another small-town coffeeshop. But for those lucky people who open the cafe door, they’re likely to be greeted with the aroma of fresh-baked goodness. This small-batch, family-owned bakery features a constantly rotating array of sweet and savory baked goods to go with your coffee – including what might just be the best pie in New Jersey. What’s the secret of this charming hole-in-the-wall? It’s a combination of inventive flavors, seasonal inspirations, international influences, and a whole lot of passion going into each and every treat. So why not discover exactly what this unique bakery has waiting for you? The odds are the answer will be different every time you visit.

The Erie Coffeeshop and Bakery in Rutherford is quickly becoming the town's go-to destination for baked goods, and one bite will make clear why.

Every item here is baked by the owners from their own recipes, and you can taste the passion in every item.

The offerings change daily and shift with the season, so you'll want to drop by regularly to see what they're offering.

You'll always find an array of bite-sized sweets, savory nibbles, and bigger treats.

However, the highlight here is definitely the homemade pies, including modern twists on favorites like lemon meringue.

The menu is heavily influenced by local and seasonal produce, so if you see the blueberry peach crumb pie on the menu, dig in - it's one of their signatures.

You'll also find an assortment of hand-held sweets like these delicious sandwiches that put your favorite oatmeal cream pies to shame.

But we can't live by sweets alone - probably! So don't ignore the savory, veggie-topped focaccia when you need a break from the desserts.

If you see the Za'atar Man'ouche, this spicy seed-topped flatbread might be the most distinct flavor sensation at the bakery!

The bakery also runs a thriving cake business, so they can create a unique shareable treat for your next get-together.

Have you visited Erie Coffeehouse & Bakery in Rutherford? Let us know what you sampled, and tell us your pick for the best pie in New Jersey in the comments section! If you’re interested in sampling for yourself, pay a visit to the cafe’s website and Facebook page to learn all about their current specials. If you’re looking for more of New Jersey’s best pies, why not try this world-famous apple orchard?

OnlyInYourState may earn compensation through affiliate links in this article. As an Amazon Associate, we earn from qualifying purchases.

Explore New Jersey

Featured Addresses

Erie Coffeeshop & Bakery, 10 Franklin Pl, Rutherford, NJ 07070, USA

Locals Can't Get Enough Of The Homemade, Seasonal Desserts At Erie Coffeeshop & Bakery In New Jersey

Raymond Goldfield

Author

Related Stories

This Seaside Country Store In New Jersey Sells The Most Amazing Homemade Fudge You'll Ever Try

This Sugary-Sweet Ice Cream Shop In New Jersey Serves Enormous Portions You’ll Love

The New Jersey Amish Country Bakery With Cinnamon Rolls As Big As Your Head

Want more New Jersey in your inbox?

Related Articles

Explore New Jersey

Featured Addresses