Decisions, decisions. We’re faced with them multiple times a day, but perhaps none is quite as harrowing as deciding what flavor pie to order. Sure, if we only have a few choices, we probably don’t have that much of a dilemma. However, when we have over 30 pie flavors from which to choose, like when we visit Peggy Jean’s Pies in Missouri, that pretty much guarantees a return visit.

You have so many pie flavors from which to choose at Peggy Jean's Pies in Columbia that you'll likely become a regular at the family-owned pie shop.
Facebook/Peggy Jean’s Pies
Owned and operated by three generations of the Plumley family, it all started decades ago with matriarch Jeanne Plumley and her close friend, Peggy Day.
Facebook/Peggy Jean’s Pies
The two opened a hugely popular pie shop that flourished for a decade - until Peggy's untimely passing. A decade later, the Plumley's decided to try again, restarting their dream with the help of a successful Kickstarter campaign.
Facebook/Peggy Jean’s Pies
Today, Peggy Jean's Pies is the place to go for the freshest, tastiest pies around, and you can enjoy one even if you aren't in town. Yep, Peggy Jean's Pies ships, How perfect is that?
Facebook/Peggy Jean’s Pies
You'll find an assortment of pie types - fruit, cream, nut, and savory - at Peggy Jean's Pies. Some are also available in sugar-free, gluten-free, or dairy-free.
Facebook/Peggy Jean’s Pies

Related Stories

There's Always A Line Down The Street At Neighbor’s Mill Bakery & Cafe In Missouri

There's Always A Line Down The Street At Neighbor’s Mill Bakery & Cafe In Missouri

 You’ll Want To Visit The Adorable Sugar Cubed Candy Store In Missouri Over And Over Again

You’ll Want To Visit The Adorable Sugar Cubed Candy Store In Missouri Over And Over Again

 The Small Town In Missouri Boasting World-Famous Pie Is The Sweetest Day Trip Destination

The Small Town In Missouri Boasting World-Famous Pie Is The Sweetest Day Trip Destination
Once you hone in on the type of pie you want, you've got the delicious dilemma of deciding the flavor or flavors. And you have a whole lot from which to choose.
Facebook/Peggy Jean’s Pies
The menu features all of the classics - American apple, cherry, and key lime, for example.
Facebook/Peggy Jean’s Pies
You'll also find such decadent options as chocolate banana, peach raspberry, and sweet potato.
Facebook/Peggy Jean’s Pies
Don't forget to take a peek at the petite tarts, the pot pies, and the quiche.
Facebook/Peggy Jean’s Pies
Head over to the official website of Peggy Jean's Pies for days, hours, and a list of pie flavors. Or, go here for Facebook.
Facebook/Peggy Jean’s Pies

Have you been to Peggy Jean’s Pies in Missouri? What’s your favorite pie flavor? Let us know in the comments! Next time you’re hungry, pair a meal with a slice of homemade pie for dessert at Beckett’s Cafe in Joplin.

OnlyInYourState may earn compensation through affiliate links in this article. As an Amazon Associate, we earn from qualifying purchases.

Related Articles

Explore Missouri

Featured Addresses
Peggy Jean's Pies, 503 E Nifong Blvd Suite C, Columbia, MO 65201, USA