8 Unsuspecting Restaurants In Indiana With Food So Good It Should Be Illegal

There’s always a restaurant with great food nearby in Indiana, but some of the best places are tiny, hole-in-the-wall eateries. You should never judge a restaurant by its exterior and these 9 unsuspecting restaurants in Indiana prove that logic to be true.

Melinda A./Yelp

Todd P./Yelp

This shrimp house restaurant in charming Madison looks like it's seen better days, and may not tempt you to stop inside from the exterior alone. However, passing up on this hidden gem means passing up on some of the most delicious seafood (including an incredible coconut shrimp) that you've ever experienced. FInd it at 117 Ferry St, Madison, IN 47250.

Advertisement

Pop P./Yelp

Advertisement

Yelp

This no frills diner doesn't look like much, but the food is no joke. This classic greasy spoon offers breakfast all day and a huge range of delicious ala carte choices. Visit them at 1600 East Main St, Richmond, IN 47374.

Nichole K./Yelp

Abhi J./Yelp

This simple Thai restaurant isn't as decked out as other eateries in the city, but you'll be impressed by their extensive and authentic Thai dishes. They offer plenty of vegan and vegetarian options as well, so everyone can eat here without hassle. Find them at 936 Virginia Ave, Indianapolis, IN 46203.

Doug B./Foursquare

Icarly S./Foursquare

This cash only pizza joint offers an amazing selection of pizza sold by the pie or by the slice. Check out their beloved spinach and feta pizza or indulge i their gyro or ranch pizzas. Check them out at 2011 Lincoln Ave Evansville, IN 47714.

Advertisement

Related Stories

8 Scrumptious Restaurants In Indiana You Never Even Knew Existed

The Most Mouthwatering BBQ In Indiana Is Found At This Tiny Restaurant

This Indiana Restaurant Is So Remote You’ve Probably Never Heard Of It

Vincent S./Yelp

Vincent S./Yelp

This Elkhart restaurant offers an incredible variety of food, ranging from their popular broasted chicken, to fish and chips, to gyros, and even wings. This is a must visit for a filling and inexpensive lunch. Find them at 921 Johnson St, Elkhart, IN 46514.

Heaher H./Yelp

Amy W./Yelp

This diner is famous for its incredible breakfast offerings such as their homemade biscuits and gravy. They even have a unique spin on the tenderloin sandwich. Give it a try at 100 N Calumet Rd, Chesterton, IN 46304.

Jdupke1/Zomato

Advertisement

jdupke1/Zomato

This tiny cafe in Anderson is a local legend when it comes to breakfast food, but they offer a pretty delicious lunch menu as well. Check it out next time you're in town at 28 E 13th St, Anderson, IN 46016.

Brownie's Bean Blossom/Facebook

Brownie's Bean Blossom/Facebook

This no frills restaurant may look dated, but their food is some of the best comfort food you'll find in Indiana. Try their country fried pork, catfish, and homemade pie for a real treat. Find them at 5730 N State Rd 135, Morgantown, IN 46160.

Have you ever been to one of these unsuspecting restaurants? Which was your favorite? For more great restaurants to try, check out these 8 retro restaurants in Indiana.