Choose From More Than 15 Flavors Of Scrumptious Pie When You Visit Lisa’s Pie Shop In Indiana
Indiana has a couple of dishes that really do scream INDIANA! The world-famous tenderloin is a big one for sure, and then there are the sugar cream pies. Oh, yes. All the pie goodness. Well, hiding in plain sight in Atlanta is one of the best little pie shops in the entire Midwest. Lisa’s Pie Shop in Indiana is one of those places you stumble upon only once in a lifetime or so, and we here in Indiana are ridiculously lucky to call Lisa’s our own.

It's open for dine-in or carry-out, and you can even order online or by phone and have it ready for you to come pick it up in a satisfyingly short amount of time.

At the time of this writing, there are more than 15 available flavors, including classics like apple, pumpkin, peach, and rhubarb, as well as other amazing varieties like Hershey bar, butterscotch, and even caramel-apple walnut!


Lisa and her pies are known as some of the best not just around the Midwest, but around the world. These pies have won countless awards and are sure to please every member of your family, no matter what their favorite is.

Sometimes it's hard to cut into a pie that looks so perfect - and that's pretty much Lisa's expertise: a delicious, beautiful, edible work of art that her happy customers can take home.

You can also pick up delights like cookies, bread (pumpkin bread, anyone?), rolls, cakes, and even quiche! Everything from Lisa's is wonderful.

If you'd like to order a delicious pie from Lisa's Pie Shop in Indiana, you can do so by calling 317-758-6944. You can also order online on the official website.
There, you can also find lots of photos, the full menu of available pies, and so much more.
What’s your favorite pie shop in Indiana? Will you be getting a pie from this amazing little place? We sure hope so!
OnlyInYourState may earn compensation through affiliate links in this article.
Address: 5995 US-31, Atlanta, IN 46031, USA