Sometimes, finding authentic Mexican food – or any food from outside the US, really – is pretty tough in the Midwest. Let’s face it: we’re 1,000+ miles away from the natural source, so our best bet is to hope some folks move up here and bring the amazingness with them. We personally enjoy highlighting little spots like that – after all, where else are you going to find the best Mexican restaurant in Indiana? We’ll do the legwork for you – you just bring your appetite and enjoy! This little mom-and-pop joint, for example, is easily the favorite when you ask the locals in Indy where to find the best Mexican ’round here. It’s Festiva Indianapolis, and trust us: it’s a party 24/7. Or, well… when it’s open, anyway.

Festiva's name is definitely appropriate.
Festiva/Facebook
It really is precisely that: festive in feeling and décor, from top to bottom. Every day here is a delicious party, both for you and your loved ones plus each and every one of your tastebuds. The feel of a restaurant can make such a huge difference to the experience overall.
Festiva is a much-beloved spot among the locals for reasons that become intensely obvious as soon as you sit down.
Festiva/Facebook
The service is superb, the overall atmosphere is fun and lively, and the menu is absurdly flavorful. It's a refreshing change from the more traditional American offerings around.
The presentation of every dish is (almost) as remarkable as the flavor.
Festiva/Facebook
It prides itself not just in this culinary brilliance, but also in its uniqueness, offering numerous items that you won't find anywhere but here. Plating can really be the cherry on top of an already delicious dish, and that's definitely the case on the Festiva Indianapolis menu.

Related Stories

On Your Way To Lake Michigan, Enjoy A Meal At This Hidden Gem Thai Spot In Indiana

On Your Way To Lake Michigan, Enjoy A Meal At This Hidden Gem Thai Spot In Indiana

 This Restaurant In Indianapolis Might Be The Best-Kept Secret In Indiana

This Restaurant In Indianapolis Might Be The Best-Kept Secret In Indiana

 You'll Be Transported To An Amish Wonderland At This Top-Rated Restaurant In Indiana

You'll Be Transported To An Amish Wonderland At This Top-Rated Restaurant In Indiana
It does enjoy being a family-friendly joint, of course, but it's also an excellent option for a first date (or 50th): it was named one of the best places for a date night in Indianapolis.
Festiva/Facebook
Numerous outlets (including us, by the way) have called Festiva a solid part of ANY best of Indiana lists. We - and the locals - are inclined to strongly agree with this consensus. It's a good one. No matter why you go for dinner at Festiva, you're going to have a fabulous time.
Plus, if you've got that one person in your party who's not into Mexican food, great news: there are also absolutely killer ribs, chicken, and steaks on the menu.
Festiva/Facebook
There's nothing here that isn't 200% excellent, and the kitchen prides itself on being able to deliver awesomeness for literally every single soul who orders something. Even the pickiest of eaters in your party will find something to love at this vibrant restaurant.
Order anything. Seriously. You can't go wrong, so go now.
Festiva/Facebook
Festiva is easily the best Mexican food restaurant in Indianapolis - we think it might just be one of the best Mexican restaurants in the entire nation, and it's right here in the Hoosier State!

For the most up-to-date menu, specials, hours, and more, be sure to visit the official Festiva website. They’re always adding new, seasonal menu items to enjoy.

Have you been to Festiva Indianapolis? What are your favorite Mexican restaurants in Indiana? Let us know in the comments below. We love to hear your firsthand accounts of these unique experiences.

OnlyInYourState may earn compensation through affiliate links in this article. As an Amazon Associate, we earn from qualifying purchases.

More to Explore

Best Restaurants In Indiana

CC | February 08, 2024

Where are the best restaurants in Indiana?  

Festiva definitely makes this list, but eating at this delicious Mexican restaurant might make you wonder what other food the state has to offer. We’ve got you covered. Check out the best restaurants in Indiana while you’re on a restaurant-hopping kick.

  • The Vine - Elkhart
  • Willie's Sports Café - Lawrenceburg
  • Pho Saigon - Indianapolis
  • The Beef House Restaurant & Dinner Theatre - Covington
  • Bonge's Tavern - Perkinsville
  • Das Dutchman Essenhaus - Middlebury
  • Joseph Decuis - Roanoke
  • Joe Huber's Family Farm & Restaurant - Borden
  • Sara's Harmony Way - New Harmony
  • The Schnitzelbank Restaurant - Jasper

 

What are the best country restaurants in Indiana?

It’s not that difficult to find delicious food in a city, where chefs and diners flock for high-quality restaurants. But sometimes the hometown feel is what hits the spot. If you’re looking for some comfort food and Midwestern charm, head to one of these country restaurants in Indiana.

  • Essenhaus
  • Farmhouse Cafe & Tea Room
  • Honeysuckle Hill Bee-Stro
  • Joe Huber's Family Farm & Restaurant
  • Lucrezia Ristorante
  • Schwartz Family Restaurant
  • Stream Cliff Farm, Restaurant & Winery
  • The Schnitzelbank Restaurant
  • The Nashville House

Related Articles

Explore Indiana

Featured Addresses
1217 E 16th St, Indianapolis, IN 46202, USA