Nothing beats a small town restaurant with hearty food, friendly service and a low key atmosphere. The following are nine of what we consider to be the most underrated, modest and satisfying restaurants in Ohio. They're the kinds of places where you'll feel right at home—even if it's your first visit.
1. Heggy's Nut Shop (Canton)
This hotdog, sandwich and burger joint serves up some of the Canton area's favorite food. (Be sure to get a side of the butter fries when you stop here.) Heggy's Nut Shop Address: 3200 Tuscarawas Street West, Canton, OH, 44708
2. Buckeye Express Diner (Bellville)
If you take exit 165 off of Interstate 71, you'll find this iconic not-your-average diner. (Note: Michigan fans must park across the street.) Buckeye Express Diner Address: 810 State Route 97 West, Bellville, OH, 44813
3. Covered Bridge Pizza Parlor (North Kingsville)
A unique and delicious pizza eating experience awaits you at this one of a kind pizza joint. Covered Bridge Pizza Parlor Address: 6541 South Main Street, North Kingsville, OH, 44068
4. The Coffee Cup (Massillon)
Massillon's oldest restaurant is proud to be Massillon's oldest restaurant, (and rightfully so.) With breakfast served all day, hearty burgers and all meals made from scratch, you really can't ask for anything better. Address: 426 Third Street Southeast, Massillon, OH, 44646
5. The Spot To Eat (Sidney)
Both literally and figuratively, this is the spot to go to for a tasty, classic cheeseburger in Sidney. What started out as a chuck wagon more than 100 years ago is now a stationary old fashioned eatery that will make you feel like you've temporarily stepped foot into a Happy Day's episode. Address: 201 South Ohio Avenue, Sidney, OH, 45365
6. Uncle Beth’s BBQ (North Lewisburg)
From hearty pulled pork sandwiches to mouthwatering brisket, Uncle Beth’s BBQ in North Lewisburg has it all—not to mention homemade desserts that are to die for. It’s a somewhat unassuming restaurant that’s the perfect example of a hidden gem. You have to travel off the beaten path somewhat, but the journey is totally worth it. Address: 6262 OH 245, North Lewisburg, OH, 43060
7. Nancy’s Main Street Diner (Grafton)
Don't make the mistake of skipping out on dessert or a fountain soda at this old-fashioned, beloved diner. Nancy's Main Street Diner Address: 426 Main Street, Grafton, OH, 44044
8. Rebecca’s Bistro (Sugarcreek)
Located in the village of Walnut Creek, coming here almost feels like you're visiting a friendly neighbor for the afternoon, rather than eating at a restaurant. Housed in a restored log cabin that was built in the early to mid-1800s, you'll feel right at home at Rebecca's Bistro. (And you really can't go wrong with anything you order at Rebecca's, as everything is prepared with the freshest ingredients and local produce.) Address: 4986 Walnut Sreet, Sugarcreek, OH, 44681
9. Sam's Place (Blakslee)
Since 1922, this family-owned establishment's been serving up exceptional food at reasonable prices in the small town of Blakeslee. When you stop at Sam's Place, you've got to try one of their signature steaks. Address: 230 Washington Street, Blakeslee, OH, 43505
Have you ever been to any of these restaurants before? If so, we want to know what your experience was like!
For more delicious restaurants in Ohio, check out our previous article: 9 Country Restaurants In Ohio That Are So Worth The Trip.
Subscribe to our newsletter
Get the latest updates and news
Thank you for subscribing!