Wyomingites are unique, in that it doesn’t take a hot day to have us craving ice cream. We get such mild summer weather that we’re conditioned to enjoy a shake or a sundae no matter what the mercury says! If you’re looking for the best milkshakes in Wyoming, head to Casper, where you’ll find the retro malt shop at Johnny J’s Diner.

Johnny J's is an old fashioned, retro diner in Casper, Wyoming.
Facebook / Johnny J's Diner
As soon as you walk in, you'll feel like you've stepped back in time! The vintage decor is one thing that makes this diner truly unique.
Facebook / Johnny J's Diner
The menu is full of classic dishes, like bacon cheeseburgers, fries, chicken, and tater tots.
Google Local / Korrin Francis

Related Stories

This Old School Ice Cream Parlor In Wyoming Will Take You Back In Time

This Old School Ice Cream Parlor In Wyoming Will Take You Back In Time

 This Tiny Creamery In Wyoming Makes Ice Cream Sandwiches That Are Out Of This World

This Tiny Creamery In Wyoming Makes Ice Cream Sandwiches That Are Out Of This World

 The Old Fashioned Soda Fountain In Wyoming Serves More Than 30 Flavors Of Ice Cream Float

The Old Fashioned Soda Fountain In Wyoming Serves More Than 30 Flavors Of Ice Cream Float
Johnny J's is known for making delicious desserts. People drive from all over to order a slice of pie from their bakery.
Google Local / Shawn Lusky
Recently, their Oreo milkshake was named best milkshake in Wyoming, and we certainly agree.
Facebook / Johnny J's Diner
The handmade shakes here are absolutely delicious. Whether you order chocolate, strawberry, hot fudge, or something unique, you will be oh so happy with every spoonful.
Facebook / Johnny J's Diner
So head out to Casper and stop by Johnny J's. This retro diner serves up the best milkshakes in Wyoming!
Facebook / Johnny J's Diner

You’ll find Johnny J’s at 1705 E 2nd St, Casper, WY 82601. For more of the best sweet treats in the Cowboy State, visit These 10 Ice Cream Shops In Wyoming – they’ll make your sweet tooth go crazy!

OnlyInYourState may earn compensation through affiliate links in this article. As an Amazon Associate, we earn from qualifying purchases.

Related Articles

Explore Wyoming