There is an old saying: “Don’t always judge a book by its cover.” The same goes for restaurants in Wyoming. Just because a restaurant doesn’t quite look up to par, it doesn’t mean that the food they serve isn’t good. Some of the best food in Wyoming can be found at some of the most unexpected places. Here is our list of the best unassuming hole in the wall restaurants in Wyoming.

1. Silver Spur Cafe
Haywood M. Smith, Jr./Google Maps
Silver Spur Cafe, 832 N Main St, Sheridan, WY 82801, USA
Brian Garrett/Google Maps
This is one restaurant that you will not leave hungry. Silver Spur Cafe is a mom 'n pop style diner that is located at 832 N. Main Street in Sheridan. Be sure to try one of their cinnamon rolls, pancakes and omelet. This is a great stop for breakfast. If you're there for lunch, check out the bacon cheeseburger around.
2. The Kaffee Klatsch
The Kaffee Klatsch Facebook page
Kaffee Klatsch, 640 S Seneca Ave, Newcastle, WY 82701, USA
Facebook/The Kaffee Klatsch
If you are looking for a different dining experience, then check out the Kaffee Klatsch. For breakfast they serve breakfast sandwiches and for lunch, they serve dishes such as calzone, chicken cordon-bleu, a pulled pork sandwich and a German specialty. Kaffee Klatsch is located at 701 Washington Blvd. in Newcastle.
3. The Busy Bee Cafe
Sally Miller/Google Maps
The Busy Bee Cafe wyoming
Rickey Muncy/Google Maps
The Busy Bee is a favorite dining spot for both locals and visitors. Breakfast, lunch and dinner are served in a dining room that overlooks Clear Creek. Some of their dinner specials include chicken fried steak, ribs, steak and beef. The Busy Bee Cafe is located at 10 N. Main Street in Buffalo.
4. Su Casa
Su Casa Café Facebook page
Su Casa Café, 705 West Lincoln Hwy, Sinclair, WY 82334, USA
Su Casa Café Facebook page
Su Casa serves some of the best Mexican food in Wyoming. A lot of people go to Sinclair just to eat at Su Casa. Some of their menu items include enchiladas, sopaipillas, sandwiches, tostadas and fajitas. This Mexican restaurant is located at 705 Lincoln Avenue in Sinclair.

Related Stories

This Is The Most Wyoming Sound You'll Ever Hear, And We Can't Stop Listening To It

This Is The Most Wyoming Sound You'll Ever Hear, And We Can't Stop Listening To It

 Locals Can't Get Enough Of The Artisan Creations At This Made-From-Scratch Bakery In Wyoming

Locals Can't Get Enough Of The Artisan Creations At This Made-From-Scratch Bakery In Wyoming

 This Old-Fashioned Soda Fountain Is One Of The Most Nostalgic Destinations In Wyoming

This Old-Fashioned Soda Fountain Is One Of The Most Nostalgic Destinations In Wyoming
5. The Antelope Bar And Paisley Shawl Restaurant
Antelope Bar Management/TripAdvisor
The Antelope Bar and Paisley Shawl Restaurant, 416 W Birch St, Glenrock, WY 82637, USA
Antelope Bar Management/TripAdvisor
Antelope Bar & Paisley Shawl Restaurant is known for its Certified Angus Beef. Some of its main entrees consist of steak (some of the best steaks in Wyoming!), bone-in pork chops, shrimp, and chicken. This quaint restaurant is located in the Higgins Hotel in Glenrock.
6. Svilar's Bar And Steak House
Facebook/Svilar's Bar And Steak House
Svilar's Bar & Steakhouse, 173 S Main St, Hudson, WY 82515, USA
Carol Bruneau/Google Reviews
Although the interior isn't that appealing, the steak at Svilar's Bar And Steak House is exquisite. The recipes are originally from a Yugoslav family who fed the coal miners and cowboys. They also serve traditional Yugoslavian ravioli, sarma, homemade pickled goodies and bread. Their beef comes from local ranchers.
7. Branding Iron
CBS Branding Iron Facebook Page
Branding Iron, 129 W 2nd St, Casper, WY 82601, USA
CBS Branding Iron Facebook Page
The Branding Iron is located at the base of the Wind River Range at 13882 US Highway 189/191 in Bondurant. Their lunch menu consists of burgers and sandwiches and their dinner menu items include chicken, salmon, pork and steak. You'll find delicious food at this down-to-earth rustic restaurant.
8. Tumblin Tumbleweeds
TripAdvisor/Colleen213
TripAdvisor/Esteph55
Editor's Note: Tumblin Tumbleweeds is permanently closed.

Tumblin Tumbleweeds exudes a welcoming western atmosphere and serves amazing food. Some of its chicken dishes included the apple & onion chicken, chicken fried steak, bourbon chicken and chicken & dumplings.

Have you ever been to this/to any of these longstanding restaurants in Wyoming? If so, which ones were your favorites? Would you agree that these are among the best small town restaurants in Wyoming? What other hole in the wall restaurants in Wyoming would you add to the list? We’d love to read about your experience in the comments section below!

We know that some of out there are big foodies, and take lots of culinary road trips. You might consider trying these awesome food containers for snacks in between your gastronomic adventures!

If you’re in the mood for more Wyoming adventures, take a look at this video:

 

 

 

OnlyInYourState may earn compensation through affiliate links in this article. As an Amazon Associate, we earn from qualifying purchases.

More to Explore

More to Love about Wyoming

Lysa Allman-Baldwin | July 24, 2023

Where can we find small towns in Wyoming?

  • Glenrock is a popular small town, in part because it sits at the foothills of the Rocky Mountains and along the Deer Creek Tributary System.
  • Cokeville is a former trading post and home to a ferry that ran across Smiths For
  • Dubois is a big draw for artists, writers, musicians, and photographers.

Read on to learn more about some of the many other charming small towns in Wyoming.

Where can we find hiking trails in Wyoming?

  • The Artists Paintpots Trail leads to some hot pots and pools in Yellowstone National Park.
  • The Glacier Trail leads to the highest peak in Wyoming in the northeastern section of the Wind River Range.
  • The Heart Lake Trail is a backcountry trek that takes hikers into the wilderness of the Greater Yellowstone Ecosystem.

Read on to learn more about some of the many other fun hiking trails in Wyoming.

What are some things to do in winter in Wyoming?

  • Sinks Canyon State Park offers year-round yurts that are the perfect getaway in the winter.
  • The town of Pinedale is one of the most popular places for people to enjoy some of the best snowmobile trails.
  • Riding the Snow King Mountain coaster is one of the most popular winter activities in the state.

Read on to learn more about some of the many other things to do in winter in Wyoming.

Related Articles