On September 11, 1857, one of the most horrific massacres in U.S. history occurred in Southern Utah. It played a tragic piece in Utah history that many still reflect upon today. While the story is heartbreaking and awful, it is creepy and spooky as well. In fact, today, the Mountain Meadows Massacre site is said to be the most haunted place in Utah.

The Baker-Fancher wagon train was made up of men, women, and children from Arkansas who were traveling through Utah to California. The wagon train was attacked by a group of Mormon Militia on September 11, 1857.
Sally T/Tripadvisor
During the attack, between 120 and 140 men, women, and children were slaughtered. The Mormon militia fabricated a story, blaming the Paiute for the massacre. They hastily buried the bodies in shallow graves, which were promptly dug up by coyotes and other wild animals. Within a few days of the massacre, bodies and body parts were scattered over two miles, left to rot in the sun.

The youngest members of the party were spared, and the 17 surviving children (all of whom were under the age of seven) were "adopted" by local Mormon families. When the childrens' relatives from Arkansas attempted to take the children back home, they were refused. It took two years, and intervention from the U.S. Army, for the children to be returned.
News of the massacre made national headlines and people all over the country were horrified.
Harpers Weekly/Wikimedia
This ink drawing of the victims' bodies was placed on the cover of Harpers Weekly. After the initial outrage, nearby settlers collected the most obvious body parts and buried them, mostly in two mass graves.

Related Stories

Step Inside The Creepy, Abandoned Town Of Thistle In Utah

Step Inside The Creepy, Abandoned Town Of Thistle In Utah

 Spend The Night At Utah's Most Haunted Campground For A Truly Terrifying Experience

Spend The Night At Utah's Most Haunted Campground For A Truly Terrifying Experience

 Tell This Utah Ghost Story Around The Campfire And No One Will Sleep A Wink

Tell This Utah Ghost Story Around The Campfire And No One Will Sleep A Wink
Throughout the years since the massacre, many visitors to this area report that it's haunted.
Sally T/Tripadvisor
Mostly, people report an eerie feeling of being watched. But, some say that they hear the cries of children, women screaming, and men shouting. Since the dead weren't properly buried, it would make sense that the pioneers who were butchered so violently would not be at rest.

A few visitors have reported seeing a woman walking across the meadow, acting as though she's searching for something — perhaps her children? Others report seeing school-aged children running through the fields, laughing.
These aren't the only reports of paranormal activity at this historic site.
Dutchkathy/TripAdvisor
There are a few accounts of an older man, seen in broad daylight at the memorial, sobbing. He's wearing clothing from the 1800s and is thought to be the ghost of John D. Lee, the man who was executed by firing squad for the massacre. Lee was the only man punished for the crimes, and historians believe he was a scapegoat to divert attention from other officials who knew about, ordered, and orchestrated the massacre of so many innocent people.
If you've never visited the Mountain Meadows Massacre, take time to stop by this memorial. It's located off U.S. Highway 18, near St. George.
Kent B/Tripadvisor
If you sit quietly and listen, you just might hear the voices of the dead on the wind.

This article only briefly touches on the details of the Mountain Meadows Massacre. For more in-depth information about this horrific tragedy, you can read our feature article.

Do you think the Mountain Meadow Massacre site is the most haunted place in Utah? Have you visited the area? Did you see or hear anything creepy there? If so, let us know in the comments!

OnlyInYourState may earn compensation through affiliate links in this article. As an Amazon Associate, we earn from qualifying purchases.

More to Explore

Most Haunted Place In Utah

Courtnie Erickson | November 01, 2021

Where can I learn Utah history?

Utah's history is quite unique when compared to other states around the country. No matter where you go in the Beehive State, you will come across many interesting and important stories. Promontory Point, located in the northern part of the state, is one of these interesting and historic destinations. In 1869, the last spike was driven to complete the Central Pacific Railroad and Union Pacific Railroad. Today, you can visit this area and learn more by taking tours, hiking, and participating in various programs.

Spring City is a small pioneer-era town that is a must-visit destination if you want to learn more about Utah history. This entire town is listed on the National Historic Register. Of course, another important piece of Utah history is the small Southern Utah town of Parowan. This town is filled with historical homes and buildings including the Jesse Smith Pioneer Home and the Old Rock Church Museum.

Where are some of the most haunted places in Utah?

While the site of the Mountain Meadow Massacre is considered one of the most haunted places in Utah, there are several other spooky destinations that you may want to visit if you love a good fright. The Heber City Cemetery is rumored to be haunted by multiple spirits. You may see a young girl playing by the headstones and at night, you may hear laughter and footsteps when nobody is around.

The Rio Grande Depot in Salt Lake City is another one of the most haunted places in Utah. This location is rumored to be haunted by the Purple Lady, a woman who wears a purple hat and dress from the early 1900s.

Related Articles

Explore Utah

Featured Addresses
Mountain Meadows Massacre Site, Mountain Meadow Monument Trail, Central, UT 84722, USA