Cincinnati Is Home To The Best Reuben Sandwiches And Here Are The 8 Places To Find Them
By Andrea Limke|Published March 13, 2018
×
Andrea Limke
Author
A Cincinnati native who has lived in Kentucky for over 10 years, Andrea's heart belongs both in the Queen City and the Bluegrass State. After earning an education degree and working in that field for a number of years, Andrea began to pursue her passion for writing over 6 years ago. Since then she has written for a number of print and online publications, as well as published a children's book.
Cincinnati has a rich German heritage and that is perhaps most evident in our food and drink options throughout the city. One classic German favorite also happens to be a favorite of many Cincinnatians and several local restaurants serve up this mouthwatering sandwich. The Reuben is a gooey, warm, delicious mixture of flavors that is really unlike any other sandwich. The salty corned beef, sauerkraut, Swiss cheese, and 1000 Island dressing all magically combine to create one unforgettable meal. And if the classic Reuben happens to be one of your favorite sandwiches, you’re lucky to live in Cincinnati, because we have the absolute best Reubens and here are 8 places to find them.
1. Carl's Deli - 2836 Observatory Ave., Cincinnati, OH 45208
Carl's Deli is an iconic shop in Cincinnati that happens to serve the best of every kind of sandwich, including the Reuben. You can get it with the traditional corned beef or with turkey, and they offer plenty of mouthwatering sides to go with it.
Izzy's has been satisfying Reuben cravings since 1901, making it one of the oldest restaurants in Cincinnati. With 9 area locations, this local favorite is a sandwich destination and the Reuben is the most popular item on the menu. You have to try it with a potato pancake and a side of their famous pickles.
With its original location in Hyde Park and another in Anderson, Arthur's is well known as a casual hangout with great burgers, but it should also be known for its tasty Reuben that comes served on grilled marble rye. And if you're lucky, you can catch the Goetta Reuben as the special and really try a Cincinnati-inspired dish.
Tag's Cafe is a lovely little dining spot in Colerain with tons of great, homemade food. Every meal of the day is delicious here, and their Reuben is one of the standouts! They make their own 1000 Island dressing, which makes this sandwich extra special.
It seems only fitting to include Cincinnati's oldest restaurant and most authentic German eatery on this list. This may actually be the ultimate destination for Reuben lovers, because not only do they have a classic Reuben sandwich, but other favorites are Reuben eggrolls and the sauerkraut balls, shown above.
6. Price Hill Chili - 4920 Glenway Ave., Cincinnati, OH 45238
Price Hill Chili is famous for their Cincinnati-style chili and classic breakfast options, but did you know they have one of the best Reubens in the city? You can get a corned beef or turkey version and both are grilled to gooey perfection.
Dutch's in Hyde Park is a hidden gem that looks like a bar - and is one - but also serves some of the best sandwiches in the city. Their version of the Reuben uses mouthwatering pastrami and it's perfectly placed inside soft rye bread with all of the delicious toppings.
8. The National Exemplar - 6880 Wooster Pike, Mariemont, Ohio 45227
The National Exemplar in Mariemont is a beautiful, historic spot to enjoy a meal. All of their food is scrumptious, including their classic Reuben. But they know how to do burgers especially well and if you get lucky, you'll find the popular Reuben burger on the menu.
Even if you’re not a fan of the Reuben, your mouth is probably still watering after checking out this list. Did your favorite Reuben spot make our list? If not, let us know and be sure to also let us know your absolute favorite Reuben sandwich in Cincinnati!
And if you prefer a different type of sandwich, check out the other best places in the city for one here.
OnlyInYourState may earn compensation through affiliate links in this article. As an Amazon Associate, we earn from qualifying purchases.
