If you’re familiar with New York, then you know that tucked away in remote areas of our state you can find unbelievable hidden treasures. Out in the Thousand Islands, adventurous divers can explore the underwater worlds that lie at the bottom of Lake Ontario. With that said, many of our residents still manage to pass right by sunken towns on a daily basis and never even realize it! Right in the Catskill Mountains, you can discover handfuls of historic towns that have been wiped off of the map to create reservoirs, including Neversink, NY.

Ironically named Neversink and Bittersweet, two historic towns of New York were submerged back in 1953.
Between The Lakes
That's right! The town of Neversink will forever remain underwater. Many of our residents who don't live in this region of New York will be surprised to hear just how many towns were destroyed back in the early 1900s.

But why was the state of New York sinking towns and farms left and right? The Big Apple had a thirst to be quenched! As New York City's population steadily increased, our state decided that it was time to create new reservoirs in the Catskill that would provide drinking water to the city.
By the time the small town was destroyed, it had roughly 2,000 residents who were not happy about what was happening to their homes.
Between The Lakes
Thanks to Between The Lakes you can see a small glimpse of what the town once looked like. Pictured above, you can get a taste of how small Neversink really was, with a district schoolhouse that only was equipped with two rooms.
Now hidden nearly 200 feet below the Neversink Reservoir's surface, the small town was once full of charm.
Between The Lakes
If you've visited the Catskills then you know that this region is filled with remote small towns that are full of friendly faces and mass amounts of charm. When the Board of Water Supply decided in 1941 that the two towns were to be written off of the map, nearly all of the town's residents were upset by the decision.

Related Stories

This Giant Portal In New York City Connects Viewers To Others In Dublin, Ireland

This Giant Portal In New York City Connects Viewers To Others In Dublin, Ireland

 Come Along As We Enjoy An Affordable Weekend Getaway To The Finger Lakes In New York

Come Along As We Enjoy An Affordable Weekend Getaway To The Finger Lakes In New York

 The Three-Liter Margarita Tower At Mad Dog & Beans In New York Is Over-The-Top And Outrageously Delicious

The Three-Liter Margarita Tower At Mad Dog & Beans In New York Is Over-The-Top And Outrageously Delicious
Founded in 1798, Neversink featured a picturesque covered bridge, a main street, a Methodist church, and more.
Between The Lakes
If you've never lived in a town that had to be relocated, then you may not be familiar with the huge hassle that comes with this process. Residents of these sunken Catskill towns were forced to relocate their businesses, homes and even passed on loved ones that were buried in the towns' cemeteries.
On June 4th, 1953, the two towns were flooded by the Neversink River when the Neversink Reservoir was created.
Daniel Case/Wikimedia Commons
Google Maps
Many of our residents are unfamiliar with the fact that the town of Neversink remains underwater because the town relocated to just down the road. Today, the new Neversink can be found in Sullivan County and as of 2010 has a population of 3,557 residents. Pictured above, you can see how close the town and the reservoir are to each other.
While most who drive along Route 55 and the Neversink Reservoir don't realize exactly what's hiding underneath the surface, some claim to be able to see the towns' ruins when the water is low.
Daniel Case/WikiMedia Commons
Another popular reservoir with a sunken town? The Ashokan Reservoir that's also located in the Catskills. In 2002, while we were experiencing a severe drought, residents claimed to be able to see the tops of barns and churches that were sunk when the Ashokan Reservoir was created in the early 1900s.

So, did you know that handfuls of sunken towns were hiding under the Catskill Mountain's reservoirs? The next time you drive along Route 55 and are soaking in the sights of one of our largest man-made reservoirs, know that the original town of Neversink is hiding just below the surface!

Get an aerial view of the Neversink Reservoir:

There’s nothing quite like stumbling upon a hidden treasure like Neversink, NY! For more adventures that fall off the beaten path, check out this hidden destination in New York that only locals know about.

OnlyInYourState may earn compensation through affiliate links in this article. As an Amazon Associate, we earn from qualifying purchases.

More to Explore

old neversink ny

Jackie Ann | July 14, 2022

Are there any good swimming holes in New York?

Good swimming holes in New York include:

  • Peekamoose Blue Hole
  • Split Rock Falls

 

There are a plethora of good swimming holes in New York, and there’s actually one not too far from Neversink, New York. Peekamoose Blue Hole is one of the best swimming holes in New York and is pretty much a natural water playground. There are rock ledges to jump off of (carefully), crystal-clear water to relax in, and some of the most stunning scenery around. If you’re in the Adirondacks, a dip under Split Rock Falls is the perfect way to spend a summer day. The trail to the falls is short and sweet, and you’ll be rewarded with beautiful blue waters and a gushing waterfall to swim around.

What are the most charming small towns in New York?

The most charming small towns in New York include:

  • Livingston Manor
  • Alexandria Bay

 

There are so many charming small towns in New York that are worthy of a day trip. Not too far from Neversink, New York is Livingston Manor, a tiny town with beautiful water views, covered bridges, cozy bed and breakfasts, and delicious restaurants. Further north, you’ll find another one of New York’s charming small towns, Alexandria Bay. Nestled along the St. Lawrence River in the Thousand Islands Region, Alexandria Bay is full of outdoor adventure any nature lover would enjoy.

Are there any ghost towns in New York?

Ghost towns in New York include:

  • Tahawus
  • Doodletown

 

Like any other state, New York has its fair share of ghost towns. The abandoned town of Tahawus in Essex County is a ghost town in New York that’s oddly enough been abandoned not once but twice! Once in 1857 and then again in 1963. While much of the original town has not survived over the years, you can still go visit the town and see the artifacts that have survived, particularly some memories from the town’s mining history. Another fascinating ghost town in New York is Doodletown. Located within Bear Mountain State Park, this is a beautiful area in the fall and there are plenty of hiking trails that will lead you around both the park and the ghost town.

Related Articles

Featured Addresses
Neversink, NY 12765, USA