We all know there are dozens of great steakhouses in Indiana – practically anywhere you go in the Hoosier State, you’ll find good steaks! From the famous St. Elmo to the highly-underrated Galveston, there’s no shortage of good beef here. If you’re looking to try a new Indiana steakhouse that’s a little away from the hustle and bustle of the Hoosier cities, then you’ll love this incredible steakhouse we’ve found in the middle of nowhere. For a delicious meal, a relaxed atmosphere, and even some live music, head to Montgomery’s Steakhouse, a place many consider to have the best steak in Indiana.

Montgomery's Steakhouse is located in the tiny town of Spiceland. This is the kind of place you either stumble upon by accident or hear about from a friend.
Montgomery's Steakhouse/Facebook
This classic steakhouse in Indiana boasts big flavor in a secluded setting, and it just may be Indiana's best-kept secret when it comes to steaks.
Inside of Montgomery Steakhouse, you'll find classic, rustic decor and a laid-back atmosphere. It's perfect for a night out with friends or a family dinner.
Montgomery's Steakhouse/Facebook
Country music is usually playing through the speakers, and the waitstaff is friendly and helpful. The extensive menu here is quite impressive for a steakhouse, and it's no wonder this place frequently wins awards for best steaks in Indiana and best BBQ.
Start your dining experience off with the mouth-watering shrimp cocktail appetizer, complete with a house-made cocktail sauce. You also can't go wrong with a rib basket, smothered in Montgomery's beloved homemade BBQ sauce.
Montgomery's Steakhouse/Facebook
Of course, you'll have to try one of the certified Angus beef steaks as an entree. The porterhouse and filet mignon are favorites, though the prime rib is definitely a contender, too.
Montgomery's Steakhouse/Facebook

Related Stories

Enjoy The Freshest Lake Michigan Seafood At At This One-Of-A-Kind Restaurant In Indiana

Enjoy The Freshest Lake Michigan Seafood At At This One-Of-A-Kind Restaurant In Indiana

 Some Of The Best Tenderloin In Indiana Can Be Found At Jonesy's Junction

Some Of The Best Tenderloin In Indiana Can Be Found At Jonesy's Junction

 This Tiny Seafood Spot May Just Be The Best Kept Secret In Indiana

This Tiny Seafood Spot May Just Be The Best Kept Secret In Indiana
If someone in your dining party doesn't eat steak, don't worry! There are plenty of other options, from salads and sandwiches to burgers and pasta.
Lorrie E./Foursquare
The bourbon pork chop, topped with bourbon sauce and a pineapple slice, is always a big hit. If you have room for dessert, you've got to try the tuxedo mousse cake, classic cheesecake, or chocolate cake with a cookie crust. You'll be amazed by the richness of the incredible desserts here.
In warmer weather and on special occasions, there's always something fun going on here. Private parties are often scheduled, and you can also find community gatherings here.
Montgomery's Steakhouse/Facebook
Montgomery's Steakhouse frequently has live music on the weekends, as well as comedy performances. This is an incredible place to spend a Saturday night unwinding with good food, great drinks, and fantastic entertainment.
Montgomery's Steakhouse/Facebook
This is just one more reason this hidden gem steakhouse in Indiana is worth a visit!
If you ever find yourself passing through Spiceland, be sure to make a pit stop at Montgomery's Steakhouse for an unforgettable experience. This is one Indiana steakhouse that's worth the drive!
Sunny66611/TripAdvisor

Have you ever been to this incredible hidden Indiana steakhouse? Do you think it’s got the best steak in Indiana? Share your experience with us in the comments and be sure to let us know about your other favorite hidden gem restaurant in Indiana.

For more information about this great restaurant, check out the Montgomery Steakhouse Facebook page.

For more great places to enjoy a phenomenal steak, check out these 9 incredible restaurants in Indiana.

OnlyInYourState may earn compensation through affiliate links in this article. As an Amazon Associate, we earn from qualifying purchases.

More to Explore

steakhouses in indiana

andrea limke | January 10, 2020

What are the best steakhouses in Indiana?

When choosing to dine out, there aren't many better options than a classic steakhouse. Indiana has many from which to choose, whether you prefer fine dining or a hidden gem. For some of the best steakhouses in Indiana, check out this rustic option, this Indianapolis favorite, or even some of the best small town options.

What is the fanciest restaurant in Indiana?

Indiana has a variety of restaurants throughout the state if you're looking to treat yourself to a fine dining experience. We have romantic eateries, some that sit right along the water, others with different fantastic views, and plenty of other white tablecloth, wine-pouring dining destinations that will delight in every possible way. For a plethora of these restaurants, check out this search on our website.

What are the best hidden gem restaurants in Indiana?

Some of the best eateries in our state could be considered a hidden gem restaurant in Indiana. These are the places that you may drive by, but never stop, or a friend tells you that you absolutely must give it a try. We love these local restaurants that often serve up the best food in the state. For a list of some of them, check out 11 of the best hidden gem restaurants in Indiana.

Related Articles

Explore Indiana

Featured Addresses
Montgomery's Steakhouse, 5800 South, 5800 IN-3, Spiceland, IN 47385, USA