As local travel experts, we know what travelers are looking for when it comes to finding the perfect accommodations for their next trip. To compile our lists, we scour the internet to find properties with excellent ratings and reviews, desirable amenities, nearby attractions, and that something special that makes a destination worthy of traveling for.

If you’re on the hunt for historic inns in Indiana, look no further! Filled with charm, vintage decor, and a ghost here and there, these fascinating getaways will give you a memorable experience.

Forget cookie-cutter hotel rooms and lobbies. These one-of-a-kind Indiana inns may become your new home away from home. Check them out:

1. The Inn at Irwin Gardens
Facebook/The Inn at Irwin Gardens
Though it has only been an Indiana B&B since 2010, the building this hotel is in was actually built as a private home in 1864. Over the years, many expansions took place, including the addition of gardens (which are open to the public). Get more information about The Inn at Irwin Gardens.
2. Blue Jay Manor
Facebook/Blue Jay Manor
Editor's note: Unfortunately, this site is permanently closed. This countryside inn is a dream home come true. It's a Queen Anne Victorian estate that became a hotel in 2014. It features grand staircases, a wrap-around porch, and luxury amenities that guests love. Learn more about this historic hotel here.
3. Indianapolis Union Station
Crowne Plaza Indianapolis-Dwtn-Union Stn, an IHG Hotel, 123 W Louisiana St, Indianapolis, IN 46225, USA
Management/TripAdvisor
Today owned by Crowne Plaza, this ancient train station was built in 1953. And it is truly one of the most historic places to stay in Indiana. Guests who stay at this working station may choose to experience sleeping in a Pullman train car. Learn more about staying at the Indianapolis Union Station.

Related Stories

Getaway And Unwind Surrounded By Nature In The Indiana Forest

Getaway And Unwind Surrounded By Nature In The Indiana Forest

 Stay In This Cozy Little Birdhouse Cabin In Indiana For Less Than $200 Per Night

Stay In This Cozy Little Birdhouse Cabin In Indiana For Less Than $200 Per Night

 Experience Industry Turned Luxury At One Of Indiana's Oldest Hotels

Experience Industry Turned Luxury At One Of Indiana's Oldest Hotels
4. Roads Hotel
Roads Hotel, 150 E Main St, Atlanta, IN 46031, USA
Facebook/Roads Hotel
Originally built in 1893, this notorious hotel is known to be haunted. Several of the original owners died in the hotel, and gangsters regularly used this place, bringing who knows what with them. You can stay in this Indiana inn for fun or schedule your own paranormal investigation. Learn more about Roads Hotel.
5. West Baden Springs Hotel
West Baden Springs Hotel, 8538 W Baden Ave, West Baden Springs, IN 47469, USA
Flickr/Scutter
What might be the eighth wonder of the world, this gigantic hotel was built more than 100 years ago and features a 200-foot-wide atrium. This massive resort is awash with Hoosier history. Learn more about one of the most historic inns in Indiana.
6. French Lick Springs Hotel
French Lick Springs Hotel, 8670 IN-56, French Lick, IN 47432, USA
Management/Trip Advisor
Thought to be the crown of Southern Indiana, this legendary hotel was constructed in 1845 and is rumored to be haunted. Though the luxurious decor of this historic place to stay in Indiana is enough to draw you in, the eerie tales associated with this place may draw you out. Read further on about the French Lick Springs Hotel.

Have you ever stayed at these historic inns in Indiana? What are your favorite Indiana B&Bs? Tell us in the comments!

For more unique hotels, check out these 11 little-known inns in Indiana for a memorable overnight stay.

OnlyInYourState may earn compensation through affiliate links in this article. As an Amazon Associate, we earn from qualifying purchases.

More to Explore

Exploring Indiana

Rachel Raimondi | June 10, 2023

What are the best restaurants in Indiana?

Now that you know about historic places to stay in Indiana, what about other things to do here? Head out for the night to some of the best restaurants in Indiana:

  • Mississippi Belle: Get some southern soul food at this restaurant in Indianapolis. Some of the most popular orders include fried chicken, meatloaf, and mac and cheese.
  • Willie and Red’s Smorgasbord: This American restaurant is located in Hagerstown. Be sure to try their prime rib, fried chicken, or ribs. And check out the working water wheel in the Mill Room.
  • The Kopper Kettle: Located in Morristown, this former 19th-century roadside inn offers up American cuisine. Enjoy the unique décor as the inside is dressed in the style of the period. Grab the farm-raised catfish, filet mignon, or fried chicken.

 

Which state parks should I visit in Indiana?

Spend the day at some of the best state parks in Indiana:

  • Brown County State Park: At 15,776 acres, this state park in Nashville is the largest in the state. Explore the hills and ravines via over 18 miles of hiking trails. You can also fish, horseback ride, mountain bike, and even camp here.
  • Spring Mill State Park: Located in Mitchell, there is a lot to do within this park’s 1,358 acres. Explore caves, visit the Grissom Memorial, check out the Pioneer Village and its over 20 historic buildings, or head out on a hike. You can also swim, boat, and camp here.
  • Fort Harrison State Park: You’ll find this 1,700-acre park in Indianapolis. Get a history lesson on the fort at the on-site museum or keep your explorations outside. There are hiking trails to roam as well as opportunities to fish and horseback ride.

 

What are the most unique towns in Indiana?

No matter where your Indiana B&B is, be sure to explore some of the unique towns in Indiana.

  • Nashville: Nope, not that Nashville. This one is located in Brown County. And instead of ties to country music, here, you’ll find historic sites, country roads, and tons of great shopping and dining. And if you want to spend some time outdoors, head to Lake Monroe for swimming, boating, and fishing.
  • Lafayette: This Tippencanoe town is home to Purdue University as well as plenty of historic buildings and beautiful outdoor areas like the Tippecanoe River County Park and Prophetstown State Park.
  • Charlestown: With a prime location on the Ohio River, this Clark County town offers some great outdoor opportunities through places like the Charlestown State Park. Other great spots for exploration include Rose Island.

Related Articles

Explore Indiana