menu search

7 More Haunted Places In Indiana That Will Give You Goosebumps

Did you survive investigating the Five Haunting Ghost Legends In Indiana? Congratulations! We were sure we would have lost a few people during their investigations! We’ve done some digging and learned there are even MORE haunted and ghostly places in Indiana worth checking out (or maybe worth staying far away from…) Anyway, enjoy and remember to bring a camera!

1.) Anderson – Cry Baby Bridge

There are a few different stories regarding what happened at this bridge. Some say a desperate mother threw the baby over the bridge. This story goes on to say that if you go to the bridge you can hear the baby crying and see the outline of the mother walking across the bridge. Another story suggests the baby died in a car accident. Either way, you are supposed to hear the cries of a baby who passed away on this spooky bridge.

2.) Indianapolis – The Hannah House

The Hannah House was originally constructed in the year 1858. Rumor has it that it was a passage for the Underground Railroad. According to legends, there was a group of slaves who were asleep in the house when an oil lantern turned over, caught some hay on fire, and killed a few of them who were hiding in the basement. I don’t know about you, but this video (and this house) gives me the creeps!

3.) Gary – The Demon House

There is a house in Gary, Indiana that is rumored to have been a portal to hell. The story goes that more than 200 demons attacked and possessed a mother (Latoya Ammons) and her children. Police officers, Child Protection Services, and medical professionals all confirmed that Latoya and her family were possessed and had to be exercised.

4.) Mitchell – Whispers Estate

Dr John and Jessie Gibbons purchased this house sometime between the end of the 1800’s and the beginning of the 1900’s (the date varies from one source to the next.) The couple was reported to have adopted a number of abandoned children. They had a ten year old girl who started a fire in the parlor in the front of the house and was burned badly. She ended up dying a couple days later in one of the bedrooms upstairs. Legend has it that you can still hear the girl running and playing upstairs.

The infant, Elizabeth, was just 10 months old when she died in the master bedroom. The cause of her death is not known. Jessie died in the same room as the infant after suffering from double pneumonia. Some say you can smell baby powder and hear labored breathing when you’re alone in this room. Some people have even claimed that they feel like someone is sitting on their chest, making it hard for them to breath.

Some even believe there are four graves on the property as well as a put that’s said to contain internal organs, fetuses, and amputated limbs.

5.) The Haunted Shiloh Church & Cemetery

This haunted spot gives me the super creeps! You can find it at the top of devil’s dip which is located just on the outskirts of Logansport. Legend has it that if you go the church near midnight and run around the church three times, you can see the face of a small child appear in one of the basement windows.

6.) Greencastle – Boone Hutch Cemetery

This cemetery is supposed to be one of the top 10 most haunted places in the state of Indiana. It’s said to contain the ghost of a police officer from the 1950’s who sits on one of the gravestones in the graveyard. He is said to carry a blue light with him. As you can see in this video, there are a lot of people who get very ghostly pictures while visiting this creepy spot!

7.) Daleville – Witches Circle – Sharps Cemetery

This cemetery is buried deep in the woods of Daleville, Indiana. It’s rumored to be haunted by an old man who used to live close to the cemetery until he died and a woman in white. Legend has it this was a circle for witches to perform black magic. There may even still be witches who come here today to perform witchcraft. Spooky!

There you have it! Seven additional haunted places in Indiana that are worth investigating. Whether you’re into this stuff and you’re planning a road trip, or this stuff terrifies you and you’re making a list of places to avoid, we hope you enjoyed this creepy list! Don’t forget to share this haunting list with all of your friends! If you know of any other scary places we forgot to mention, please tell us about them in the comments below!

Trisha Faulkner
Trisha Faulkner is a stay-at-home and work-at-home Hoosier momma. She is a huge advocate of Autism awareness, and loves her beautiful boy more than life itself. She is a native Indiana writer who types her best pieces for Only In Your State between 2-4AM when her toddler finally falls over asleep.