If you have a mighty sweet tooth, you’ve come to the right place. From our refreshing key lime pies to our epic ice cream creations, the Sunshine State is known for whipping up magnificent sweet treats. You’ve never tasted anything like these 11 unique desserts in Florida. Which will you try first?
1. Pies from Yoder's Restaurant & Amish Village in Sarasota
Yoder's is a Sarasota landmark and has been a local favorite since it opened in 1975. Every bite of this comfort food is delicious, but they are most well-known for their homemade pies. Order a few and you will be the most popular guest at any party! To learn more about these scrumptious pies, visit Yoder's Restaurant and Amish Village's website.
At 23,000 square feet, this is one of the largest candy shops in the country. But it's not just about quantity. Sweet Pete's makes some of the best, highest quality candy you will ever try. With thousands of choices, there's something to satisfy every sweet tooth. Visit Sweet Pete's Candy Shop's website to learn more.
This iconic Key West restaurant serves its own special version of our official state pie, piled high with meringue. What a slice of heaven. To learn more about these mouthwatering key lime pies, visit Blue Heaven's website.
4. Ice cream from Love Boat Ice Cream in Fort Myers
This ice cream shop has been a local favorite for over 50 years. They create homemade ice cream in a dizzying array of flavors, from strawberry cheesecake to salted caramel bacon. Visit Love Boat's website to learn more about these magnificent treats.
This local landmark has been serving sandwiches to hungry Tampanians since 1963, but they're equally famous for their cakes. The Southern classic hummingbird cake is a customer favorite. For a detailed list of their spectacular creations, visit Wright's Gourmet House's website
6. Pie from Fireman Derek's Bake Shop & Cafe in Miami
This funky shop in Miami's Wynwood district bakes some of the best pies in South Florida. There are many delicious varieties available, but the Key lime pie and chocolate pecan pie are our favorites. Learn more by visiting Fireman Derek's website.
With locations in Destin, Panama City Beach or Santa Rosa Beach, there are plenty of opportunities to visit this long-standing cafe. Obviously, The Donut Hole Cafe and Bakery is famous for their donuts and breakfast food, but their dessert case is also a thing of beauty. They are well known for their Key lime pie and sky-high layer cakes.
8. Cinnamon rolls from Knaus Berry Farm in Homestead
Lines stretch all the way out to the road for Knaus Berry Farm's fresh cinnamon rolls. If you don't consider cinnamon rolls dessert, this lovely farm also offers several other sweets, including cookies, brownies, and pies. Please note: They are only open to the public from late October to mid-April.
This hidden gem restaurant in Florida is located in Dunnellon on US 41. At The Front Porch, you'll find a seemingly endless array of fresh-baked goodness, so feel free to order a few different slices. Everything is divine, but we recommend the coconut cream or chocolate coconut cream pie.
The Fat Donkey is famous for their Zonkey, which is an artful layering of soft serve and Italian ice or sorbet. If you want something a little richer, try the Jack Smasher, created by smashing a piece of cheesecake or Key lime pie into an ice cream cone, followed by strawberries and layers of soft serve, topped with cool whip.
11. Sweet treats from Toothsome Chocolate Emporium in Orlando
Toothsome Chocolate Emporium, located at Universal Orlando’s CityWalk, brings to mind Willy Wonka’s Chocolate Factory. It's not surprising that they specialize in all kinds of sweets. Their ridiculous milkshakes steal the show, though, especially the crowd favorite, the red velvet milkshake topped with a red velvet cupcake.
Have you had any of these unique desserts in Florida? What’s your favorite place for a sweet treat in the Sunshine State? Share your thoughts with us in the comments below! And if you know another must-visit eatery, nominate it for a chance to be featured.
Craving a cold and creamy treat? Then you should embark on the ultimate ice cream trail through Florida. This adventure will take you to the best ice cream parlors in the Sunshine State.
